Shenzhen was no Yalta, but Asia was not asked

Eighty minutes around a table at Kylin Villa in Shenzhen produced a four-point declaration. It named one international court and zero wars. Chinese President Xi Jinping, U.S. President Donald Trump, and Russian President Vladimir Putin agreed to reform the United Nations, curb the International Criminal Court, keep talking about nuclear risk, and put more refined petroleum on the market.
Three governments started drafting rules for everyone else. The rest of Asia was not even in the room.
Published summaries say nothing about Russia’s war in Ukraine, the U.S.-led war in Iran, Taiwan, or the South China Sea. Instead, the text singles out the ICC. That is the same court opening the trial of former President Rodrigo Duterte on Nov. 30 on three counts of crimes against humanity. None of the three leaders in Shenzhen belongs to the ICC, and Putin has been wanted by it since March 2023 over alleged war crimes in Ukraine. The Philippines left the court in 2019, though Duterte’s case moved forward because the alleged killings happened before the exit. Summaries of the declaration say the three powers invoked “state consent,” a principle that would make future prosecutions much harder to pursue (note: the full text has not been released, so the exact wording remains unverified). Filipinos remain divided over Duterte. Even so, three non-members are now debating the reach of international justice.
Ukraine fared no better. The New York Times reported that the war came up inside the room, yet it vanished from the final text. Afterward, Putin said he would not negotiate with Kyiv. U.S. and European estimates put Russian troop losses at 400,000 to 500,000, but Putin still walked out with equal billing and an invitation to next month’s Group of 20 summit in Florida.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy warned of a “second Yalta,” pointing to the 1945 conference that carved up postwar Europe. That parallel only goes so far. Ying-Yu Lin of Tamkang University in Taiwan called the comparison a stretch because no borders were drawn in Shenzhen. The three could not even agree to open arms control talks after New START expired in February. China holds an estimated 500 warheads against more than 5,000 each for the U.S. and Russia, and Beijing refused to be lumped into the same category. As Council on Foreign Relations president Michael Froman wrote, Taiwan and Ukraine were absent from the table, yet “not on the menu.”
That describes one meeting. Chim Lee of The Economist Intelligence Unit expects more trilateral summits ahead. Putin called the format useful. Xi opened by declaring that “a transformation not seen in a century is accelerating,” echoing the exact line he gave Putin in Moscow three years ago. Trump says he wants to pull Beijing and Moscow apart. Still, Xi and Putin have met more than 40 times, and China has bought Russian oil throughout the war. Trump has just over two years left in office. Xi and Putin have no term limits and no named successors. Asia will be dealing with the two who stay.
For Manila, the timing is jarring. Trump stopped in the Philippines just two days earlier for the ASEAN summit,meeting President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. and Quad leaders. By Marcos’s count as ASEAN chair, negotiators have finished 85% to 90% of the South China Sea code of conduct. Then Chinese state news agency Xinhua reported that Trump assured Xi the U.S. does not support Taiwan independence. On Friday, Taiwan’s Mainland Affairs Council Minister Chiu Chui-cheng called that claim “not true” and asked Washington to clarify (needs verification: Washington has not confirmed what Trump told Xi).
Batanes sits closer to Taiwan than to Manila. Malacañang has every reason to ask Washington three direct questions: What did Trump tell Xi about Taiwan? Did the West Philippine Sea come up at Kylin Villa? Does the Mutual Defense Treaty mean the same thing in Washington this week as it did in Manila on Tuesday?
The summit deserves some credit. Leaders who talk miscalculate less, and a country with one oil refinery can use more diesel on the global market. Still, the three governments promising U.N. reform already hold vetoes in it.
Asia does not need their permission to hold its ground. The Philippines holds a 2016 arbitral award under the U.N. Convention on the Law of the Sea rejecting China’s nine-dash line, and no trilateral declaration can repeal it. ASEAN can finish the code of conduct when Singapore takes the chair next year. Manila can get Washington’s assurances in writing. Having turned Duterte over to the ICC in March 2025, Malacañang should also state plainly where it stands on the Shenzhen language regarding that court.
Nobody at Kylin Villa was taking notes for Manila.
Comments (0)
LEAVE A REPLY
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!
Related Articles

Politics and the scientific method
The Pax Silica initiative offers opportunities to attract investment and participate in strategic semiconductor, artificial intelligence, and advanced manufacturing supply chains. But it also raises important questions about land use, indigenous peoples’ rights, environmental protection, employment and the distribution of economic benefits. The fundamental question remains to be this: Who

Private school vouchers: help or hype?
Imagine a mother in a provincial town looking at two schools for her child, who is about to enter first grade. The public school is free but crowded and farther from home. The private school is just a tricycle ride away and has smaller classes, but the tuition is beyond what

The ‘pax’ we know not
“All we are saying is give peace a chance.” The famous line comes from the Plastic Ono Band’s 1969 recording of “Give Peace a Chance,” produced by the late John Lennon and his wife, Yoko Ono. In Latin, “peace” translates to “pax,” which reminds us of Pax Silica, the initiative a so-called
