Politics and the scientific method
By Michael Henry Yusingco, LL.M
The Pax Silica initiative offers opportunities to attract investment and participate in strategic semiconductor, artificial intelligence, and advanced manufacturing supply chains. But it also raises important questions about land use, indigenous peoples’ rights, environmental protection, employment and the distribution of economic benefits.
The fundamental question remains to be this: Who will ensure that these opportunities translate into genuine public benefits rather than merely expanding the commercial interests of politically connected businesses? This is where Congress should come in.
Unfortunately, we have reason to question whether our legislators appreciate the magnitude of their responsibility in preparing the country for the Fourth Industrial Revolution. Technological transformation is already reshaping industries, employment, education, commerce and public administration. Yet our legislative institutions often appear content to react to executive initiatives rather than independently examine their implications.
This is another governance tragedy unfolding before our eyes. Congress is constitutionally equipped to scrutinize executive action, investigate matters in aid of legislation and establish the legal safeguards necessary to protect the public interest. These powers should be especially important when government enters into major economic and technological partnerships.
Voters need to understand that lawmaking is fundamentally a problem-solving exercise. Politics, at its best, is the organized process through which society identifies common problems, negotiates competing interests and develops collective solutions. It should therefore be informed by evidence, systematic investigation and reasoned deliberation—not political convenience or business lobbying or what many of us would call as ‘politics as usual’.
In Making Laws That Work: How Laws Fail and How We Can Do Better, jurist David Goddard makes an important observation:
“The first step in designing legislation that works is to identify and describe the relevant social problem, and the desired social change.”
This is precisely why the 1987 Constitution gives Congress the power to conduct inquiries in aid of legislation under Article VI, Section 21. This authority is not principally intended to provide televised political entertainment, investigate crimes or determine criminal liability. Its fundamental purpose is to help legislators understand problems that require legislative intervention.
This constitutional mandate serves three important functions.
First, it provides a forum for communities to articulate their concerns. Legislators must understand how proposed economic and technological developments affect ordinary Filipinos, workers, businesses and local communities.
Second, it allows subject matter experts to explain the complexities of the problems being addressed. In the case of Pax Silica, this should include experts in artificial intelligence, semiconductor manufacturing, labor, environmental protection, indigenous peoples’ rights, competition and investment regulation.
Third, it enables Congress to identify potential risks and unintended consequences before enacting laws. What happens to displaced communities? Who owns the resulting infrastructure? What safeguards protect national interests? How will Filipino workers participate in the value chain? Who benefits from public investments and incentives?
These questions cannot be answered through rubber-stamping executive proposals or relying exclusively on the assurances of prospective investors. Lawmakers must, instead, adopt a process akin to what our learners would call as ‘the scientific method of inquiry’.
The Marcos administration deserves recognition for successfully staging the 49th ASEAN Summit and its related meetings. The Philippines presented itself as a capable regional leader, and President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. highlighted more than 100 outcome documents covering regional cooperation, digital integration, energy security and other priorities.
But voters and taxpayers should be realistic: diplomatic visibility and summit accords do not automatically translate into better lives for Filipinos. We must demand our lawmakers to perform their constitutional duties to interrogate these agreements. The question is no longer simply whether the administration can attract investments. It is whether our institutions can ensure that these investments serve the public interest.
Comments (0)
LEAVE A REPLY
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!
Related Articles

Shenzhen was no Yalta, but Asia was not asked
Eighty minutes around a table at Kylin Villa in Shenzhen produced a four-point declaration. It named one international court and zero wars. Chinese President Xi Jinping, U.S. President Donald Trump, and Russian President Vladimir Putin agreed to reform the United Nations, curb the International Criminal Court, keep talking about nuclear risk, and put more refined petroleum on the market. Three governments started drafting

Private school vouchers: help or hype?
Imagine a mother in a provincial town looking at two schools for her child, who is about to enter first grade. The public school is free but crowded and farther from home. The private school is just a tricycle ride away and has smaller classes, but the tuition is beyond what

The ‘pax’ we know not
“All we are saying is give peace a chance.” The famous line comes from the Plastic Ono Band’s 1969 recording of “Give Peace a Chance,” produced by the late John Lennon and his wife, Yoko Ono. In Latin, “peace” translates to “pax,” which reminds us of Pax Silica, the initiative a so-called
