Private school vouchers: help or hype?
By Herman M. Lagon
Imagine a mother in a provincial town looking at two schools for her child, who is about to enter first grade. The public school is free but crowded and farther from home. The private school is just a tricycle ride away and has smaller classes, but the tuition is beyond what the family can comfortably afford.
She would probably like to have a choice. The family budget, however, has already made much of that decision for her.
That is why the newly reported Basic Education Voucher Assistance Act deserves attention.
President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. signed Republic Act No. 12327 on Nov. 12, 2026, the Presidential Communications Office reported. The law expands government assistance for qualified learners attending participating private basic education schools, with greater support intended for poorer households. The expansion to kindergarten and elementary school is expected to begin in the 2027–28 school year, subject to funding.
I welcome the development, although I have learned to be careful whenever a promising education reform comes with the word “voucher.” Parents still have to ask how much it covers, what expenses remain, and whether their preferred school qualifies.
A voucher worth PHP 15,000, for example, would certainly help with a PHP 25,000 tuition bill. But the remaining PHP 10,000 is still a serious amount for a family juggling groceries, electricity, transportation, and school supplies. That is an illustration, not an announced voucher rate. For many parents, affordability is decided by what remains unpaid.
On Sept. 4, I wrote a column titled “Private Schools Matter, Too.” I argued that our education debates too often treat public and private schools as competitors when both have important roles in educating Filipino children. I also worried about smaller provincial schools quietly struggling with declining enrollment, rising costs, and the loss of teachers to better-paying institutions.
I wrote from experience. My mother taught in private higher education for 40 years, while I spent 21 years teaching in private basic education. I studied in private schools for 18 years, from high school through my master’s degree, and am now taking another graduate course in Bacolod. My daughters attended Ateneo de Iloilo tuition-free through my employment, although other fees alone were twice what some private schools charged altogether. Like me, they eventually attended a state university, giving my pocket some welcome breathing room. As a student, teacher, and parent, I have experienced the strengths and financial pressures of both systems.
The new law is a welcome development in that discussion. Government assistance can follow qualified learners into private schools with available capacity, potentially easing congestion in nearby public classrooms. Participating schools and teachers may also benefit from salary subsidies, training, and scholarships.
That is encouraging, particularly for small private schools that cannot match government compensation. I remember how difficult it could be to lose a capable teacher to a better-paying position. Nobody could reasonably blame someone for wanting a more secure livelihood. But every departure meant another round of recruitment, adjustments, and uncertainty.
Still, vouchers are not a rescue package for every private school. Nor should they be.
Paqueo and colleagues (2025) found that vouchers can make private schooling more affordable. The catch is that the assistance has to be enough, reach families who truly need it, and arrive without unnecessary problems.
I share those concerns. What good is a voucher if parents still cannot afford the balance or if poorer families are left out? And for small private schools, delayed government payments can mean worrying about how to make the next payroll. I know that struggle from my years in private education.
The law addresses some of these problems. Voucher values are to be reviewed periodically, poorer learners are to receive greater assistance, and payments to participating schools are supposed to be released within 60 days after the schools submit all required documents. The Department of Education is also tasked with monitoring school quality and learner outcomes.
Those are worthwhile safeguards. Whether they work will depend on implementation, not the length of the law’s title.
I am particularly interested in what happens outside major cities. A small private school in Iloilo may have classrooms available while a nearby public school struggles with congestion. But there are also barangays where no suitable private school exists. A voucher cannot create a classroom, hire a teacher, or shorten a difficult journey simply by being issued.
And there is the larger question of quality. Parents do not choose schools based on tuition alone. They consider teachers, discipline, safety, values, accessibility, and whether their children are actually learning. A voucher that makes a school affordable is helpful. It becomes meaningful when the education inside that school is worth the investment.
This is also why I remain uneasy whenever assistance to private schools is discussed as though it competes with funding for public education. It need not. Public schools still require classrooms, laboratories, libraries, learning materials, and properly supported teachers. The voucher program should complement those investments, not become an excuse to postpone them.
I remember writing in 2020 about private schools closing during the pandemic and teachers suddenly facing uncertain livelihoods. Back then, the worry was whether many schools would survive. Six years later, we are discussing a law that may give some of them renewed breathing room.
That is progress worth recognizing. But I would rather see the program judged by the children it helps than by the number of vouchers announced.
For the mother comparing two schools, the question is much simpler than the policy debate. Can she afford the remaining fees? Is there a place for her child? Will the teachers be good? Will the school deliver what it promises?
The law may finally give her another option.
The real test begins when she sits down with the enrollment form, a calculator, and the money she has managed to set aside.
***
Doc H fondly describes himself as a “student of and for life” who, like many others, aspires to a life-giving and why-driven world grounded in social justice and the pursuit of happiness. His views do not necessarily reflect those of the institutions that employ him or with which he is affiliated.
Comments (0)
LEAVE A REPLY
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!
Related Articles

Shenzhen was no Yalta, but Asia was not asked
Eighty minutes around a table at Kylin Villa in Shenzhen produced a four-point declaration. It named one international court and zero wars. Chinese President Xi Jinping, U.S. President Donald Trump, and Russian President Vladimir Putin agreed to reform the United Nations, curb the International Criminal Court, keep talking about nuclear risk, and put more refined petroleum on the market. Three governments started drafting

Politics and the scientific method
The Pax Silica initiative offers opportunities to attract investment and participate in strategic semiconductor, artificial intelligence, and advanced manufacturing supply chains. But it also raises important questions about land use, indigenous peoples’ rights, environmental protection, employment and the distribution of economic benefits. The fundamental question remains to be this: Who

The ‘pax’ we know not
“All we are saying is give peace a chance.” The famous line comes from the Plastic Ono Band’s 1969 recording of “Give Peace a Chance,” produced by the late John Lennon and his wife, Yoko Ono. In Latin, “peace” translates to “pax,” which reminds us of Pax Silica, the initiative a so-called
