SC: Napolcom flipped its own rules to dismiss ex-WV top cop
By Francis Allan L. Angelo

The Supreme Court has voided the dismissal of retired Police Chief Superintendent Bernardo A. Diaz, the former Western Visayas police director whom then-President Rodrigo Duterte publicly linked to illegal drugs in 2016. The court found that the National Police Commission (Napolcom) built its case on Duterte’s speech and ignored its own rules.
In a resolution promulgated Aug. 12, 2026, the court’s First Division said Napolcom investigated Diaz before any valid complaint existed. Four of the commission’s own employees then filed a complaint that adopted the findings of that earlier investigation.
The ruling comes almost two years after a House of Representatives Quad Committee hearing on Nov. 27, 2024. According to Diaz’s motion, as the court summarized it, Napolcom representatives at that hearing “admitted that the sole basis of the charges against them were FPRRD’s statements.” The representatives included Napoleon R. Arostique Jr., the officer who oversaw the pre-charge investigation of the dismissed officers.
FPRRD is the court’s shorthand for former President Rodrigo Roa Duterte.
“The unfairness manifested in NAPOLCOM’s disregard of its own rules of procedure in the commencement of an administrative complaint and the conduct of investigations,” the court said.
The court granted Diaz’s motion for reconsideration and set aside its own July 29, 2024 resolution, which had dismissed his petition for certiorari.
It also declared void the Office of the President’s (OP) May 10, 2022 decision and March 5, 2024 resolution in OP-DC Case No. 18-A-018.
Those rulings had found Diaz liable for grave neglect of duty. They dismissed him from the service and imposed the accessory penalties of cancellation of eligibility, forfeiture of retirement benefits, and perpetual disqualification from holding public office.
The court said its review was limited to whether the OP committed grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction.
Associate Justice Ramon Paul L. Hernando wrote the resolution as working chairperson. Chief Justice Alexander G. Gesmundo and Associate Justices Rodil V. Zalameda, Ricardo R. Rosario, and Jose Midas P. Marquez concurred. Rosario also wrote a concurring opinion.
Named in a speech
Duterte named Diaz on July 5, 2016, in a speech at the 69th anniversary of the Philippine Air Force in Clark, Pampanga. He listed Diaz as one of five Philippine National Police (PNP) generals who were supposedly protecting illegal drug operations.
The other four were retired Deputy Director General Marcelo Garbo Jr., retired Chief Superintendent Vicente Loot, Director Joel Pagdilao, and Chief Superintendent Edgardo Tinio. All five denied the allegations at the time.
In that speech, Duterte referred to Diaz as a former regional director of Region 11, news reports said at the time. Diaz in fact headed Police Regional Office (PRO) 6 in Western Visayas.
Diaz, a member of Philippine Military Academy Class 1984, served as PRO 6 regional director from June 21, 2015, until his relief on July 14, 2016.
Duterte immediately ordered Napolcom to investigate Diaz. The commission formed a team of investigators, and that team later recommended charges against him.
Investigation came before the complaint
The court traced the case to Special Order No. 16-051, dated Aug. 26, 2016. That order directed Napolcom personnel “to investigate the police personnel allegedly involved in illegal drug activities as pronounced by [FPRRD][.]”
The court said the special order “lacked any material allegations as to the offense allegedly committed by petitioner.” It only stated in general terms that Diaz was one of the officers allegedly involved in illegal drugs.
On Oct. 24, 2016, Napolcom Director Manuel L. Pontanal and lawyers Owen G. De Luna, Jacinto C. Cabus, and Jonathan R. Agaton filed a Joint Complaint Affidavit against Diaz. All four were Napolcom personnel.
The affidavit stated: “That pursuant to the directive of the President to Investigate [petitioner], the NAPOLCOM issued a Letter Order creating an Investigating Team and directing it to conduct investigation.”
The four complainants also adopted their Investigation Report dated Oct. 24, 2016. They described the report and its attachments as an integral part of the complaint.
That report said “the [i]nvestigation [t]eam recommended that further investigation be conducted . . . with respect to [petitioner] for the purpose of gathering additional evidence and for the filing of appropriate action as the evidence may warrant.”
“Clearly, before any complaint existed, an investigation has already taken place and its findings gave rise to the filing of the complaint,” the court said.
At the April 28, 2017 pre-hearing conference, Diaz’s counsel proposed a stipulation that the case stemmed from Duterte’s speech. Atty. Maximo L. Lacasa, chief of the Napolcom prosecution team, responded “admitted.”
When Diaz’s counsel pressed that the speech was the reason for the case, Lacasa replied, “that is a mandate, we are tasked.”
Rules turned upside down
The court said Napolcom Memorandum Circular No. 2016-002 (NMC 2016-002) allows only four ways to start an administrative complaint against a police officer. These are a sworn written complaint, a verbal complaint put into a complaint-affidavit, a letter-complaint later affirmed under oath, and an anonymous complaint whose allegations can be validated.
Duterte’s statements could not count as a verbal complaint, the court said, because they were never put into a complaint-affidavit with supporting documents.
Neither the special order nor the Joint Complaint Affidavit properly started the case, the court ruled.
Under Rule 14 of the same circular, a pre-charge investigation is supposed to follow a complaint, not come before it. The court said the pre-charge investigation in Diaz’s case “was seemingly reduced to a mere formality.”
The pre-charge investigation report itself acknowledged the earlier investigation, the court said. It noted that the Oct. 24, 2016 report had recommended charges of grave neglect of duty, grave irregularity in the performance of duty, grave misconduct, and conduct unbecoming of a police officer.
The Napolcom Inspection, Monitoring, and Investigation Service (IMIS) relied on those earlier findings when it recommended the grave neglect of duty charge, the court added.
Rosario wrote that Napolcom “inverted the procedural sequence prescribed under the NAPOLCOM Rules of Procedure and treated the investigation as source of the complaint, rather than the complaint as the trigger of the investigation.”
The court also rejected the possibility that the probe could pass as a motu proprio investigation, one that Napolcom opens on its own initiative. Rule 6 of NMC 2016-002 allows such probes only in five situations: a police officer firing a gun; a death, serious injury, or human rights violation during a police operation; evidence lost or tampered with in police custody; a suspect seriously injured in custody; or a violation of the rules of engagement.
“There is no evidence on record which suggests that the aforementioned circumstances existed to warrant the conduct of a motu proprio investigation against petitioner,” the court said.
The charges
Napolcom formally charged Diaz on Feb. 22, 2017, with grave neglect of duty. The charge covered his time as commander of the PRO 6 Regional Anti-Illegal Drugs Special Operations Task Group (RAIDSOTG) from June 21, 2015, to July 1, 2016.
The formal charge said Diaz “palpably failed to conduct operations against drug abuse and trafficking and failed to arrest wanted persons on illegal drugs across provincial boundaries.”
Napolcom then asked the OP for clearance to hold a summary hearing. After the OP granted it, an ad hoc committee was formed to conduct the formal investigation and receive evidence.
Napolcom eventually accused Diaz of nine counts of grave neglect of duty. Among them, it said he failed to hold chiefs of police accountable for missing accomplishment reports, failed to devise operation plans against seven known drug syndicates, and failed to staff the RAIDSOTG. It also said he failed to act on an attempted break-in and theft of a closed-circuit television camera at the Aksyon Radyo station in Iloilo City.
The other counts covered his alleged failure to hold regular adjudication proceedings against police personnel involved in illegal drugs, failure to conduct counter-intelligence operations against such personnel and against local officials, failure to send Napolcom Region 6 the list of nominees for police chief posts, and failure to direct the RAIDSOTG to produce results.
Diaz denied being involved in the drug trade or protecting drug personalities.
He said that he ordered an inventory of anti-drug accomplishments at his first command conference. When 23 chiefs of police failed to comply, he relieved them and placed them under investigation, he said.
Diaz said that operation plans were developed against all seven syndicates and submitted to the PNP Directorate for Intelligence.
He said the Iloilo City Police Office should have acted on the Aksyon Radyo incident because his office only supervised the units. Even so, his office acted against the group involved, and criminal cases were filed, he said.
Diaz also argued that the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency (PDEA) is the government’s lead agency against illegal drugs and that the PNP’s role is to go after street-level drug personalities.
To support his defense, he submitted newspaper clippings of drug arrests, attestations from police provincial directors, and an award he had received from PDEA.
Nine counts, then four
On Jan. 25, 2018, Napolcom found Diaz guilty of all nine counts and recommended his dismissal. Diaz appealed to the OP.
In its May 10, 2022 decision, issued by then-Executive Secretary Salvador C. Medialdea, the OP affirmed Napolcom’s findings. Because Diaz had already retired, the OP imposed the accessory penalties in place of dismissal.
The OP said Diaz had admitted in his counter-affidavit that 36 of the region’s chiefs of police had no accomplishment reports on illegal drug operations, and that 23 of them failed to explain why.
It said the RAIDSOTG had only one accomplishment from June 2015 to May 2016, and that operation ended with the suspect being released for further investigation.
The OP also said the operation plans Diaz cited were unsigned, and that only three were presented and signed during the pre-conference hearing.
It treated Diaz’s taking advantage of his official position and his length of service as aggravating circumstances.
On March 5, 2024, in a resolution issued by Executive Secretary Lucas P. Bersamin, the OP partly granted Diaz’s motion for reconsideration. It cut the finding to four counts because the formal charge listed only four, but it kept the penalty of dismissal.
The OP rejected Diaz’s due process claim. It said Napolcom’s decision was only recommendatory and that Diaz had received a copy of the OP decision.
Evidence brushed aside
The Supreme Court said the OP set aside Diaz’s graphs, tables, charts, and assessment reports on PRO 6 and RAIDSOTG accomplishments from 2010 to 2015 as self-serving because Diaz had prepared them himself.
The court said Diaz also submitted official progress and spot reports on RAIDSOTG operations during his term. Different police officials had prepared all of them except an Aug. 26, 2015 final report.
“However, both the OP Decision and Resolution are bereft of any discussion showing that the same had been considered,” the court said.
Rosario wrote that these progress reports struck at the core of Diaz’s defense and, had they been considered, could have disproven three of the four counts.
Citing the 1940 case Ang Tibay v. Court of Industrial Relations, the court said the OP “fell short of the standard prescribed in Ang Tibay that the tribunal must consider the evidence presented by the party.”
Right to know the charges
The court also upheld Diaz’s claim that he was not properly informed of the charges against him.
It said the gap between Napolcom’s nine counts and the four in the formal charge meant Diaz was never properly told which acts or omissions supported each count.
The aggravating circumstances the OP used were also missing from the formal charge, as required under Rule 15, Section 1 of NMC 2016-002.
The Office of the Solicitor General, representing the OP and Napolcom, had argued that the OP fixed the problem by reducing the counts to four. It also said Diaz had a chance to defend himself through counter-affidavits, a position paper, and countervailing evidence.
“The Court is not convinced,” the resolution said.
Citing Fontanilla v. The Commission Proper, Commission on Audit, the court said Diaz’s motion for reconsideration did not cure the defect.
Quoting Abutin v. San Juan, the court said “obstinate disregard of basic and established rule of law or procedure is not mere error of judgment.” Such disregard is grave abuse of discretion that certiorari can correct, it added.
Why the court took the case
In July 2024, the court had dismissed Diaz’s petition for violating the hierarchy of courts, the doctrine that cases should first go to the lowest court with jurisdiction.
The Solicitor General argued that Diaz raised factual questions, should have appealed to the Court of Appeals, and filed beyond the appeal period. On March 31, 2025, the court required the respondents to comment on Diaz’s motion.
The court this time held that Diaz’s case fell under an exception for matters “dictated by public welfare and advancement of public policy, or demanded by the broader interest of justice.”
It said the core issue was a question of law: whether grave abuse of discretion violated Diaz’s right to due process.
At the Quad Committee
In his motion, Diaz said he testified under oath at the House Quad Committee’s Nov. 27, 2024 hearing. He said he and other police officers investigated for drug-related offenses because of Duterte’s pronouncements aired their grievances there and said their dismissals lacked due process.
Arostique was a Napolcom regional official in Western Visayas. In 2017, as chief of the technical services division of Napolcom-6, he announced administrative complaints against regional police officers on Duterte’s drug list.
The Inquirer reported at the time that 19 Western Visayas policemen were on that list.
In August 2025, Daily Guardian reported that the Civil Service Commission had reinstated several of those officers, including Police Lieutenant Colonel Noel Lamsis and Police Major Rio Maymay. Napolcom had dismissed them in 2021 for incompetence and gross neglect of duty.
In that same probe, a Napolcom Western Visayas official told House members he was “not so diligent in the investigation” and had “only relied upon the pronouncement of the president” as the main basis for the cases.
The Supreme Court resolution does not make a separate finding on what was said at the Quad Committee. Its findings rest on Napolcom’s own records, including Lacasa’s admission at the 2017 pre-hearing conference. (Daily Guardian)
Comments (0)
LEAVE A REPLY
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!
Related Articles

No brakes: Cielo Magno vows candor in 2028 Senate bid
By Joseph Bernard A. Marzan ILOILO CITY — Former Finance Undersecretary Cielo Magno, an economics professor eyeing a Senate seat in 2028, said Monday, Nov. 16, that she would not change her approach once she formally begins campaigning. Magno and Ronald Llamas, a former political adviser to the late President Benigno Aquino III, met with

‘LOST IN GRAY’: Baronda’s bid to co-author youth code tests City Council’s rules
ILOILO CITY — The Iloilo City Council is grappling with whether Vice Mayor Julie Grace “Love-Love” Baronda can co-author ordinances after it adopted a Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) legal opinion limiting her role in sessions to presiding over proceedings and voting only to break a tie. The

BACK TO BASICS: MORE Power reports zero fatalities, shorter outages after lineman training
ILOILO CITY — MORE Electric and Power Corp. (MORE Power) has sent its linemen back up the poles by hand in a refresher training it links to a year without fatalities and a sharp drop in unscheduled power interruptions. The second batch of the training brought together linemen from MORE
