‘LOST IN GRAY’: Baronda’s bid to co-author youth code tests City Council’s rules
By Rjay Zuriaga Castor

ILOILO CITY — The Iloilo City Council is grappling with whether Vice Mayor Julie Grace “Love-Love” Baronda can co-author ordinances after it adopted a Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) legal opinion limiting her role in sessions to presiding over proceedings and voting only to break a tie.
The issue arose on Tuesday, Nov. 17, when Sangguniang Kabataan (SK) Federation President Jelma Crystel Implica moved for the passage of her proposed Comprehensive Youth Development Code on second and final reading.
During the deliberations, Baronda said she wanted to co-author the proposed ordinance, saying some of its provisions were based on youth-related ordinances she had previously authored.
Baronda served three consecutive terms as a city councilor from 2013 to 2022. During her tenure, she chaired the Committee on Youth and Sports Development.
Her youth-related measures include ordinances establishing the Iloilo City Youth Development Council, the Iloilo City Youth Development Division, and the Iloilo City Leadership Academy.
“Can I also co-author this (youth code) since I see a lot of the provisions of the ordinances [I passed previously are] included in the ordinance?” she said.
She cited the provisions on the city’s youth development council as an example.
“I cannot sponsor, but I can co-author. It is not prohibited, and it is not covered by the DILG opinion… It is just a matter of delicadeza,” Baronda added.
Under legislative practice, a sponsor is the councilor who formally introduces a proposed ordinance, resolution, or motion for consideration and usually explains the measure during deliberations.
An author is the councilor who develops or prepares the proposal, while a co-author substantially contributes to its drafting and shares credit for the measure.
Councilors Rex Marcus Sarabia and Nene Dela Llana left it to Implica to decide whether Baronda could co-author the measure. Implica then requested a recess.
A ‘GRAY AREA’
Sarabia said Baronda’s request placed the council in a “gray area.” He noted that he was unsure whether the Senate and House of Representatives allow incumbent or former lawmakers to be recognized as authors of measures based on legislation they had previously enacted.
Baronda, however, argued that it had been customary in the City Council to recognize incumbent councilors as co-authors when provisions from their existing ordinances were carried over into measures proposed by other councilors.
She maintained that allowing her to co-author the measure would be consistent with the council’s past practice.
Sarabia said his primary concern was not whether Baronda should be recognized as a co-author. His concern was whether doing so would be consistent with the council’s Internal Rules of Procedure (IRP), which now incorporates the DILG opinion.
On Oct. 21, the City Council’s Treñas-allied majority voted 13-1 to adopt DILG Legal Opinion No. 95, Series of 2025, into the IRP. Councilor Sheen Marie Mabilog cast the lone dissenting vote.
The adoption effectively barred Baronda from participating in floor deliberations and serving on regular legislative committees.
The majority has argued that the vice mayor, as presiding officer, does not have the same powers as regular councilors, and that adopting the opinion merely ensures compliance with existing law.
The DILG Western Visayas office, however, has said the opinion is advisory and does not have the force of law.
The DILG opinion does not specifically use the terms “authorship” or “co-authorship.” Instead, it discusses legislative initiative using the terms “introduce,” “sponsor,” and “co-sponsor.”
“My concern is that it was allowed under previous practices. So it seems to be a gray area. … I am not entirely interested in whether she should be recognized or not. What I am after is that we maintain the IRP that was adopted,” Sarabia said.
Councilor Rommel Duron, who authored the resolution adopting the DILG opinion, maintained that the council should not allow Baronda to co-author the proposed ordinance.
He also argued that the council need not rely on the legislative procedures of the Senate and House of Representatives in processing measures. He noted that the City Council operates under the Local Government Code and DILG regulations.
NOT LIFTED, IMPLICA SAYS
Implica, meanwhile, clarified that the provisions on the city’s youth development council in her proposal were based on National Youth Commission (NYC) guidelines and Republic Act No. 10742, or the Sangguniang Kabataan Reform Act of 2015.
She stressed that the provisions in her proposed measure were not directly lifted from Baronda’s previous ordinances.
She added that the proposed code also drew on legislation from other cities as references in developing a comprehensive framework for youth development.
Implica said she had invited the Office of the Vice Mayor to take part in the committee hearings.
She acknowledged that Baronda’s staff had given her information about the vice mayor’s previous youth-related ordinances.
While some provisions of previous city ordinances were incorporated into the proposed code, Implica said these were consolidated under broader areas of youth participation during committee deliberations.
After the discussions, Implica withdrew her motion to allow further review of the measure before seeking its passage.
“I think it is best if I withdraw my previous motion so we can better lay down the provisions, and then we will propose it again for the third and final reading,” Implica said.
Comments (0)
LEAVE A REPLY
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!
Related Articles

No brakes: Cielo Magno vows candor in 2028 Senate bid
By Joseph Bernard A. Marzan ILOILO CITY — Former Finance Undersecretary Cielo Magno, an economics professor eyeing a Senate seat in 2028, said Monday, Nov. 16, that she would not change her approach once she formally begins campaigning. Magno and Ronald Llamas, a former political adviser to the late President Benigno Aquino III, met with

BACK TO BASICS: MORE Power reports zero fatalities, shorter outages after lineman training
ILOILO CITY — MORE Electric and Power Corp. (MORE Power) has sent its linemen back up the poles by hand in a refresher training it links to a year without fatalities and a sharp drop in unscheduled power interruptions. The second batch of the training brought together linemen from MORE

SC: Napolcom flipped its own rules to dismiss ex-WV top cop
The Supreme Court has voided the dismissal of retired Police Chief Superintendent Bernardo A. Diaz, the former Western Visayas police director whom then-President Rodrigo Duterte publicly linked to illegal drugs in 2016. The court found that the National Police Commission (Napolcom) built its case on Duterte’s speech and ignored its
