Sara Duterte impeachment trial: What three banks told senators
By Francis Allan L. Angelo

Bank officials gave testimony before the Senate impeachment court on accounts linked to Vice President Sara Duterte, her husband, and her father, and on how banks flag suspicious transactions.
The testimony bears on Article II of the Articles of Impeachment, which covers allegations of unexplained wealth against the vice president.
Prosecutors cite PHP 4.4 billion in total transactions in the accounts of Duterte and her husband, Atty. Manases “Mans” Carpio, that appeared in records of the Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC).
The council is the Philippines’ financial intelligence unit, to which banks and other covered institutions report suspicious transactions.
Those transactions include a PHP 41 million cash withdrawal by Carpio in a single day.
Also cited are the couple’s alleged links to Samuel Kang Uy, who has been linked to illegal drugs.
Prosecutors further point to PHP 319 million in remittances from Chinese companies to Cale88 Foods Corp., a company connected to Carpio.
In addition, 34 suspicious transaction reports (STRs) filed by financial institutions are tied to allegations of graft, malversation, and anomalies in flood control projects.
An STR is not automatic proof that a crime occurred, and the transactions and the allegations tied to them remain under examination in the trial.
Cale88 accounts closed in July
Two bank accounts belonging to Cale88 Foods Corp. — a banana chips company owned by Carpio — were closed in July 2026, amid the impeachment trial, a senior Security Bank executive told the court on Wednesday.
Taking the witness stand on Day 35 of the trial, Security Bank Branch Banking Group Head Leslie Cham confirmed that Cale88 previously maintained two peso checking accounts with the bank, but both were closed three months ago.
“Yes, it appears that Cale88 has two checking accounts, but was closed already as of this point in time,” Cham testified under questioning from Senator-Judge Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan.
When Pangilinan asked when the accounts were terminated, Cham replied: “It closed on July 2026.”
Pressed for further details, Cham said Cale88’s first account with Security Bank was opened in August 2024 and its second in October 2025, and that both were closed in July 2026.
Pangilinan underscored the timeline of the corporate accounts, pointing out that they operated while Duterte was already in office and were shut down as she faced impeachment proceedings.
“When it was opened, Vice President was already Vice President. And when it was closed, of course, 2026,” Pangilinan stressed. “So from 2024 to 2025 to 2026, it would be interesting to get the information as to the amounts that went in and out, considering that in the AMLA report, about P319 million went in and or transactions from China.”
According to Cham, the closing balance for Cale88’s primary account, ending in 2013, stood at PHP 332,530.95, while the second account, ending in 8581, had an ending balance of PHP 21,164.27.
Flagged deposits and heavy turnover
The disclosure prompted pointed questioning from several senator-judges, who homed in on anti-money laundering compliance, bank due diligence, and suspicious transactions flagged by the AMLC.
Senate President Sherwin “Win” Gatchalian pressed Cham on multiple STRs that Security Bank had previously submitted on Cale88, including 12 cash deposits the bank flagged for being “not commensurate with the declared financial profile of the customer.”
Reading from the bank’s own STRs, Gatchalian said the bank found that Cale88 “failed to provide supporting documents and remained unresponsive to the request for clarification, which resulted to the bank being unable to validate the source and purpose of the transaction.”
Cham declined to elaborate on the reports during the hearing, citing bank secrecy and anti-money laundering statutory protections.
Senator-Judge Raffy Tulfo further examined the volume of funds moving through Cale88’s accounts, noting that the modest ending balances masked tens of millions of pesos in total turnover.
Pointing to an apparent discrepancy between the account’s modest ending balance and a forensic audit report, Tulfo asked Cham about the actual annual turnover.
Cham confirmed the figures, reading from the bank’s transaction ledger for 2024: total incoming funds reached PHP 40,138,766.28, while total outgoing funds amounted to PHP 40,001,101.79.
“So halos parehas lang,” Tulfo observed, noting that nearly all the money that entered the account in 2024 also left it.
Cham added that in 2025, another PHP 6,265,915.66 entered the account.
Tulfo then asked whether bank managers could waive Know Your Customer (KYC) requirements or look the other way when high-profile figures deposit large amounts.
“Eh paano kung wala yung client at tumawag yung manager niyo, tumawag yung vice president ng bank, papasukin mo na yan? Kami ng bahala?” Tulfo asked.
“We don’t do that,” Cham answered. “In fact, if there is any ambiguity on that, we always refer it to the compliance office to make the final judgment on that… We are very strict on the KYC in the compliance.”
Joint BPI account
In a separate line of questioning, defense lawyers for Duterte raised the possibility that her father, former President Rodrigo Duterte, could have made multimillion-peso transactions under a joint Bank of the Philippine Islands (BPI) account without her knowledge.
During cross-examination, Atty. Michael Poa, counsel for the vice president, underscored the former president’s authority to act without his daughter’s signature on the account registered under both their names.
“So is my understanding also correct that under this structure of the joint account, if we can call it that, former President Rodrigo R. Duterte can transact alone, singly?” Poa asked.
“That is correct. But respondent Vice President Sara Z. Duterte cannot transact alone without the consent or signature of the former President, her father,” replied BPI Central Metro Manila branches division head Marwin Galvez.
Galvez earlier confirmed, during questioning by private prosecutor Atty. James Bryan Ibrahim Alih, that a peso time deposit was opened on Jan. 22, 2010, with an initial amount of PHP 40,650,000.
“Based on the document we submitted to this honorable court, requested for by the subpoena, this time deposit account is under the name of Rodrigo Roa Duterte. Or Rodrigo Roa Duterte and Sara Z. Duterte,” Galvez testified.
The time deposit reportedly underwent 12 renewals or rollovers until it reached approximately PHP 41.72 million in February 2011.
Galvez also confirmed that the account at the BPI Julia Vargas branch was registered under “Rodrigo Roa Duterte or Rodrigo Roa Duterte and Sara Zimmerman Duterte.”
However, he noted that both the vice president and her father signed bank documents as part of the bank’s KYC rules.
Additionally, he confirmed another account at the BPI Davao Main branch, ending in 9891, under the name of Rodrigo R. Duterte, “in trust for” Sara Zimmerman Duterte — an account held by one individual for the benefit of another.
Based on records presented in court, the PHP 41,721,035.62 proceeds from the time deposit were credited on March 9, 2011, into the Julia Vargas settlement account ending in 9539, which was also registered under both father and daughter.
The same amount was subsequently used to purchase a manager’s check.
Galvez also confirmed another manager’s check transaction for the identical sum of PHP 41.72 million on Oct. 20, 2011, nearly seven months later.
This became the focus of the prosecution’s scrutiny, as prosecutors argued that funds tied up in a manager’s check might not appear in a bank account’s ending balance at the close of the year.
“The point eventually is simply that the manager’s check being circulated does not show up in the year-end balance because that money is in float,” Alih explained.
Alih added that prosecutors aim to establish a link between the PHP 41 million transaction and another PHP 55 million sum, which their forthcoming evidence will show eventually converged at the Julia Vargas branch and was used to purchase several insurance policies.
The testimony revived a controversy that first erupted in 2016, when former Sen. Antonio Trillanes IV exposed Rodrigo Duterte’s alleged undeclared millions in bank deposits, including his joint account with Sara at BPI Julia Vargas.
At the time, Trillanes accused the former president of failing to declare PHP 211 million in his Statement of Assets, Liabilities, and Net Worth (SALN).
Duterte’s camp initially denied the accusation, but he later admitted holding accounts at Julia Vargas while maintaining they contained only thousands of pesos.
Trillanes challenged him to disclose the full transaction history rather than just the remaining balance.
Presiding Officer Francis Escudero clarified that scrutinizing older transactions is allowed solely to establish a potential pattern or financial baseline, rather than to serve as an independent impeachable offense.
Suspicious transactions
Banks do not base STRs on gossip, speculation, or negative news alone, the head of Metrobank’s Anti-Money Laundering Division told the court on Wednesday.
Atty. Niña Feren Aguilar confirmed to Pangilinan that negative news is not enough for a bank to file an STR against a client.
Senator-judges stressed that STRs undergo strict review before submission to the AMLC.
Instead, the bank examines whether there is sufficient basis to question a transaction, including large deposits with no clear legal, commercial, or economic justification.
“Apart from negative media reports, you would look at this particular guideline and say, ‘Yung deposit na ito, malaking halaga and it appears na walang underlying legal or trade or economic justification,'” Pangilinan asked.
“Among others, Your Honor,” Aguilar answered.
Pangilinan emphasized that banks do not file an STR simply because of a controversial news report.
“You are careful na hindi rin tama na mag-file ng suspicious transaction report kung mali, or walang basis, or dahil news report lang. So, maingat ang banko bago ito mag-file [ng] suspicious transaction report. Binubusisi ninyo ng husto. Hindi base sa chismis,” Pangilinan stressed.
“Yes, Your Honor,” Aguilar confirmed.
Earlier, Senator-Judge Risa Hontiveros examined Metrobank’s process, asking whether a report is automatically sent to the AMLC once controversial news emerges about a depositor.
“Basta ba may controversial na balita tungkol sa kliyente ay nireport na yan agad-agad sa AMLC bilang STR o kinokonsidera po ba ng covered person, in this case ng banko, yung circumstances ng transaction?” Hontiveros asked.
“Kasama na po yung halaga, account activity profiles ng nagpadala at tumanggap ng pera at iba pa,” the senator added.
Aguilar explained that negative news about a client does not immediately mean a transaction is suspicious.
Instead, the bank first verifies whether its customer is indeed the subject of the news before conducting a deeper review of the transactions.
“For suspicious transaction reporting based on negative media, we generally file a suspicious transaction report if we have identified our customer to be the subject of the negative media and conduct further review on the transactions,” Aguilar explained.
She added that additional STRs may be filed if there is sufficient basis after the transactions are reviewed.
Hontiveros also asked who has the authority to submit an STR to the AMLC.
“Yung mga bank teller po ba ang nagpapadala ng mga suspicious transaction reports agad-agad sa AMLC o dumadaan po ba yan sa internal review?” the senator asked.
“May escalation process po ba? May approval po ba ng mga boss ng covered person o ng bangko bago i-report, i-forward ang report sa AMLC?” she added.
Aguilar confirmed that tellers and ordinary bank employees cannot simply send an STR.
Instead, reports must go through the Anti-Money Laundering Division and receive her personal approval before submission to the AMLC.
“Suspicious transaction reports […] goes through my division, anti-money laundering division and would require my approval as well before filing with the AMLC,” Aguilar explained.
Comments (0)
LEAVE A REPLY
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!
Related Articles

Permanent jobs for barangay workers? Lawmaker says it depends on funds
ILOILO CITY — Making barangay workers’ positions permanent in government remains an ideal goal, but financial constraints continue to stand in the way, Iloilo 3rd District Rep. Lorenz Defensor said on Nov. 16. Defensor recognized the need to give barangay service point officers (BSPOs), barangay health workers (BHWs), day care workers,

Election ban, utility lines delay PHP 102.8M Lapuz flood project
By Rjay Zuriaga Castor ILOILO CITY — The Department of Public Works and Highways–Iloilo City District Engineering Office (ICDEO) blamed the Commission on Elections (Comelec) construction ban, utility line obstructions, and bad weather for the nearly yearlong delay of a flood mitigation structure in Barangay Alalasan, Lapuz district. The construction ban was imposed ahead of

‘MINORS ARE NOT CONTENT’: CWC flags radio interview of minor in theft case
ILOILO CITY — The Council for the Welfare of Children (CWC) has urged media practitioners to observe responsible journalism when reporting on children in conflict with the law (CICL) after an Iloilo City-based radio station published online interviews with two minors. In a statement on Monday, the CWC condemned the interview
