Preserving more than flavors: The message of Dodoy Setubal’s Kalan-On
By Noel Galon de Leon
There is an important and potentially provocative argument embedded in Kalan-On: The Art of Food, The Food of Art, an exhibition by Cristhom “Dodoy” Setubal, that deserves closer attention beyond the visual appeal of its meticulously crafted food replicas. At first glance, the exhibition appears to be a celebration of Ilonggo and Western Visayan cuisine, presenting an extensive collection of familiar dishes, delicacies, ingredients, and culinary traditions. However, beneath the colorful and nostalgic associations of food lies a much larger question about cultural ownership, geographical identity, labor, historical memory, and the politics of gastronomy. Who actually produces the food that gives a place its gastronomic identity? Can a city claim the distinction of being a gastronomic destination without acknowledging the agricultural communities, coastal municipalities, interior towns, small-scale producers, market vendors, and ordinary workers whose labor makes its food culture possible? One of the most compelling arguments that emerges from the exhibition is that a city’s gastronomic identity cannot be understood exclusively through the boundaries of the city itself. It is often shaped by resources, knowledge, traditions, and productive forces that originate beyond its geographical and administrative borders. Food does not respect political boundaries, and neither should our understanding of culinary heritage.
This argument becomes particularly relevant when examining the distinction between Iloilo City and the province of Iloilo. There is a tendency to associate the gastronomic identity of Iloilo primarily with its urban food establishments, celebrated restaurants, culinary entrepreneurs, and commercially recognizable dishes. While these undoubtedly contribute to the city’s reputation, they represent only a portion of a much larger gastronomic ecosystem. It is important to recognize that Iloilo’s culinary heritage is deeply rooted in the agricultural, coastal, and interior communities of the province. As the artist himself clarified in his response regarding the exhibition, Iloilo’s gastronomic identity is fundamentally provincial, with the city benefiting from the substantial contributions of its municipalities and rural communities. The ingredients, agricultural produce, seafood, culinary techniques, and food traditions that eventually find their way into the city’s restaurants and markets are frequently produced elsewhere. Farmers, fishers, food processors, bolantero, market vendors, carinderia owners, and countless other workers participate in the creation and circulation of this gastronomic culture. Consequently, the recognition of Iloilo as a gastronomic destination should not become an excuse to concentrate cultural credit and economic benefits in the urban center. If we celebrate the city’s food, we must also acknowledge the provincial communities that sustain it. Otherwise, we risk turning gastronomy into another instrument of urban centralization, where the city receives the recognition while the communities responsible for producing its food remain largely invisible.
Setubal’s decision to present 79 food artworks in commemoration of the 79 years of the University of the Philippines’ presence in Iloilo adds another dimension to the exhibition. The number is not merely a curatorial detail or an exercise in artistic productivity. It establishes a relationship between food, institutional history, and regional identity. Through these 79 representations, the exhibition becomes a visual inventory of culinary memory, bringing together dishes that are familiar, ordinary, celebratory, and sometimes overlooked. The collection includes recognizable Ilonggo preparations such as laswa, KBL (kadyos, baboy, kag langka), kansi, batchoy, and inasal nga manok, alongside delicacies such as baye-baye, barquillos, biscocho, pinasugbo, butong-butong, and kalamay-sa-buri. It also features preparations associated with particular municipalities, including baye-baye from Pavia, kutsinta from Dumangas, tinuom from Cabatuan, binayabasan from Lambunao, and moron from Balasan. These geographical associations are significant because they challenge the tendency to treat Ilonggo cuisine as a homogeneous collection of dishes detached from their specific communities of origin. A food’s identity is not simply determined by its ingredients or method of preparation. It is also shaped by the people who developed it, the landscape where its ingredients grow, the local economy that sustains its production, and the collective memory through which its preparation is transmitted.
One of the most valuable contributions of Kalan-On is its capacity to make visible the relationship between food and cultural memory. Food is often discussed in terms of taste, nutrition, consumption, and commercial value, but it is equally important to recognize it as a repository of knowledge. A traditional dish carries information about agricultural practices, local biodiversity, trade routes, migration, colonial encounters, religious traditions, and household economies. The presence of Chinese-influenced foods such as siopao, siomai, cha-a, and pancit alongside indigenous and locally developed preparations demonstrates that culinary cultures are never completely isolated or culturally pure. They evolve through exchanges, adaptations, and negotiations between different communities. What we now recognize as distinctly Ilonggo or Filipino may have emerged through centuries of encounters with foreign ingredients, techniques, and culinary practices. This complicates simplistic notions of authenticity. Authenticity should not mean preserving food in an imagined state of cultural purity, nor should it require rejecting outside influences. Rather, it should involve understanding how communities receive, transform, reinterpret, and eventually make these influences their own. The more important question, therefore, is not whether a dish originated locally or abroad, but how it became meaningful within a particular community and what histories are embedded in its present form.
The exhibition also raises an important question about the ingredients themselves, particularly those that are becoming increasingly difficult to find in local markets. Beyond presenting the names of familiar dishes, Kalan-On invites us to examine the specific ingredients that make these foods possible. What are the native plants, vegetables, fruits, seafood, grains, and other agricultural products that have historically shaped Western Visayan cuisine? Which of these ingredients remain accessible to contemporary households, and which have gradually disappeared from our markets and everyday cooking practices? The references to tugabang, baringon, ubad, tambo, and other locally significant ingredients should encourage further investigation into the biodiversity and ecological knowledge embedded in regional food traditions. These ingredients are not merely components of a recipe. They are evidence of the relationship between communities and their natural environments. Their disappearance, whether caused by environmental degradation, changing agricultural priorities, overexploitation, declining demand, or climate change, also signals the possible disappearance of the dishes that depend on them. When a particular ingredient becomes unavailable, an entire culinary practice may eventually become impossible to reproduce. The loss is therefore not simply gastronomic. It is ecological, cultural, linguistic, and historical.
This is where the exhibition becomes particularly relevant to contemporary discussions about climate change, biodiversity, food security, and cultural preservation. The rapid transformation of agricultural landscapes, unpredictable weather patterns, changing coastal ecosystems, and the depletion of natural resources pose serious challenges to the continuity of traditional food systems. What happens when a fish that once regularly appeared in local markets becomes increasingly difficult to catch? What happens when a native vegetable is no longer cultivated because commercial agriculture favors more profitable crops? What happens when younger generations no longer recognize the ingredients that their grandparents once gathered, prepared, and consumed? These are not hypothetical questions. They concern the future of our regional food heritage. An exhibition such as Kalan-On should therefore encourage more than appreciation and nostalgia. It should inspire systematic documentation, community-based research, culinary archives, and collaborative initiatives involving artists, historians, anthropologists, farmers, fishers, chefs, environmental scientists, and local governments. We need more artists and researchers who are willing to investigate our own food traditions, document disappearing ingredients, record the knowledge of elderly cooks, and understand the ecological conditions that sustain local cuisine. Cultural preservation cannot depend solely on remembering the names of dishes. It must also protect the people, environments, and material resources that make those dishes possible.
Equally important is the exhibition’s reminder that the food we consume is also a reflection of the economic and cultural choices we make. Convenience has become one of the defining characteristics of contemporary food consumption. We increasingly choose products because they are readily available, inexpensive, heavily marketed, or easy to prepare. There is nothing inherently wrong with convenience or with the introduction of new food products. However, we must be careful not to allow convenience to become the primary determinant of our culinary preferences. When households gradually abandon traditional ingredients and preparations in favor of standardized commercial products, they also participate, often unconsciously, in the weakening of local food systems. The danger is not simply that younger generations may stop eating particular dishes. It is that they may eventually lose the ability to recognize, appreciate, and reproduce the flavors that have historically formed part of their cultural identity. We must ask ourselves whether our changing food preferences are entirely personal choices or whether they are also shaped by aggressive commercial marketing, unequal access to local produce, changing work arrangements, and an economic system that often privileges mass-produced food over small-scale traditional production. The disappearance of a traditional dish is rarely an isolated culinary event. It may reflect deeper transformations in agriculture, labor, consumption, and the distribution of economic power.
There is also an important artistic dimension to consider. By recreating food through detailed visual representations, Setubal challenges the conventional boundaries between art, craft, documentation, and cultural preservation. Food is ordinarily understood as something temporary. It is prepared, served, consumed, and eventually disappears. Its existence is tied to the fleeting experience of taste, smell, texture, and nourishment. Through the creation of food replicas, the artist suspends this temporary existence and transforms ordinary meals into objects of contemplation. The viewer is invited to look at food differently, not simply as something to eat but as something that can be studied, remembered, interpreted, and appreciated as an expression of cultural creativity. This artistic strategy is particularly interesting because it exposes the relationship between visual representation and the material reality of food. A replica can preserve the appearance of a dish, but it cannot fully reproduce its aroma, flavor, nutritional value, or the social experience of sharing it. This limitation is precisely what makes the exhibition worth examining. It reminds us that representation is not the same as preservation. A beautifully rendered replica may preserve the visual memory of a disappearing dish, but it cannot replace the actual ingredients, the knowledge of the cook, the agricultural landscape, or the community that gives the dish its meaning. The exhibition should therefore be understood as an invitation to continue the work of cultural documentation rather than as a substitute for the living traditions it represents.
The exhibition’s extensive list of food references also deserves a more critical reading. While the sheer number of dishes demonstrates the richness of Western Visayan cuisine, it simultaneously raises questions about classification, regional representation, and the politics of naming. Are all the dishes presented equally representative of Iloilo? What distinguishes a municipal specialty from a widely shared regional preparation? How have migration, commerce, and interregional exchanges influenced the geographical attribution of particular dishes? Are there foods associated with marginalized communities, indigenous knowledge systems, or working-class households that remain absent from the exhibition? These questions are not intended to diminish Setubal’s artistic achievement. Rather, they point toward the possibilities of expanding the conversation initiated by the exhibition. A list of dishes is a useful starting point, but a more comprehensive gastronomic history requires us to investigate the circumstances surrounding their production and consumption. We must document who prepares them, where their ingredients originate, how their recipes are transmitted, what social occasions they are associated with, and how their meanings change across generations. We must also recognize that culinary heritage is not always preserved in formal cookbooks or institutional archives. Much of it exists in the memories and practices of women, farmers, fisherfolk, vendors, household cooks, and community elders whose knowledge has historically received insufficient scholarly and institutional recognition.
In this regard, Kalan-On also offers an opportunity to reconsider the role of universities and cultural institutions in documenting and protecting regional knowledge. The fact that the exhibition commemorates the University of the Philippines’ 79 years in Iloilo should invite a broader reflection on the responsibility of academic institutions toward the communities that surround them. Universities should not merely celebrate regional identity through commemorative activities and exhibitions. They should actively participate in producing and making accessible the research that allows communities to understand their own histories. There is considerable room for collaborative research involving local food histories, ethnobotany, agricultural biodiversity, oral histories, culinary terminology, and the documentation of endangered food practices. Such initiatives could produce multilingual publications, digital archives, community cookbooks, recorded interviews, and educational materials that would benefit both researchers and ordinary readers. More importantly, these projects should not simply extract knowledge from communities for academic consumption. The people who preserve and practice these traditions must be recognized as knowledge producers and active participants in the research process. If gastronomy is to become a meaningful instrument of cultural development, the communities that sustain it must also benefit from the recognition, resources, and opportunities it generates.
The most important lesson of Kalan-On: The Art of Food, The Food of Art is that food heritage should never be reduced to a marketing strategy, a tourism slogan, or an attractive collection of dishes displayed for public consumption. Gastronomy is not simply about what a place serves to its visitors. It is about the land that produces its ingredients, the waters that sustain its seafood, the workers who prepare and distribute its food, the communities that transmit its culinary knowledge, and the histories that give meaning to its flavors. If Iloilo wants to strengthen its reputation as a gastronomic destination, it must look beyond the restaurants of the city and recognize the agricultural and coastal communities of the entire province. It must also ask whether the economic benefits of gastronomic recognition reach the farmers, fishers, small food producers, and vendors whose labor makes the region’s culinary identity possible. We cannot meaningfully celebrate local food while overlooking the conditions of those who produce it. Neither can we claim to protect culinary heritage while allowing the ingredients, ecosystems, and traditional knowledge that sustain it to disappear.
The most provocative question that this exhibition leaves us with is this: What good is it to celebrate the food of Iloilo if, in the coming years, the ingredients that give these dishes their distinctive flavors are no longer available, the people who know how to prepare them are no longer heard, and the communities that sustain them remain economically invisible? We must be careful about what we eat, what we choose to preserve, and what we allow the market to replace. Every meal is connected to a system of production, an environmental reality, and a cultural history. The flavors we take for granted today may become the flavors that future generations will only encounter in photographs, written descriptions, or meticulously crafted replicas. Setubal’s exhibition gives these foods a visible presence, but it also reminds us that their continued existence depends on decisions that extend far beyond the gallery. The challenge is not simply to remember what we have eaten. It is to ensure that future generations will still have the opportunity to taste, prepare, cultivate, and understand these foods as living expressions of Western Visayan culture. A gastronomic heritage cannot survive on recognition alone. It must be cultivated, protected, practiced, and shared.
***
Noel Galon de Leon is a writer and educator at the University of the Philippines Visayas. He teaches in the Division of Professional Education and at UP High School in Iloilo. He currently serves as Faculty-in-Charge of the UP Visayas Language Program and as Secretary of the National Committee on Literary Arts of the National Commission for Culture and the Arts (NCCA). His poetry has been recognized by the Don Carlos Palanca Memorial Awards for Literature. His art criticism essay was shortlisted for the 13th-year edition of the Purita Kalaw-Ledesma Prizes in Art Criticism.
Comments (0)
LEAVE A REPLY
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!
Related Articles

A child isn’t content
Deleting a Facebook video takes three clicks. Erasing the look on a 13-year-old boy’s face when a microphone is shoved in front of him takes much longer, especially after a whole town has already watched him break. Over the weekend, an Iloilo City radio station uploaded video interviews of two minors. Police had picked them

53
KADYA nga lampas singkuwenta anyos rën ako, mga alas-dos ukon alas-tres sa kasanagën nagabugtaw rën ako. Kato alas-kuwatro ukon alas-singko ang normal ko nga pagbugtaw. Pero kadya, pira rën ka bulan nga naobserbahan ko nga mas nagtimprano pa gid ang akën pagbugtaw. Alas-otso sa gabii nagapanguy-ab rën takën. Amo ria nga

Hanggang saan aabot ang PHP 22 mo?
Try buying lunch with PHP 22. Not cooking for a whole family. Just feeding yourself. Perhaps rice and a little ulam. If you are lucky, an egg. If you are buying from a carinderia, you might find yourself checking the prices twice before ordering. That was my first thought when I
