Pax Silica is ‘oversimplified,’ climate think tank warns
By Joseph Bernard A. Marzan

ILOILO CITY — A Quezon City-based climate think tank said on Monday, Nov. 16, that the risks and benefits of the Philippines’ Pax Silica partnership with the United States must be fully addressed and laid out to the Filipino people before the project proceeds.
Angelo Kairos Dela Cruz, executive director of the Institute for Climate and Sustainable Cities (ICSC), told ABS-CBN News Channel’s “Top Story” on Monday that Pax Silica suffered from “oversimplification.”
He cited the initiative’s expected effects on Indigenous peoples and the climate, as well as the government’s recent response to protests against it.
“Pax Silica is a significant investment, however, we do think that it suffers greatly from oversimplification. I think, [for] something as big as this, we have to recognize that it is complex,” Dela Cruz said.
“It will require a lot of conversations, not only among ASEAN leaders, but also among the government officials involved, but more importantly, with the communities affected, the indigenous peoples, and so on,” he added.
Dela Cruz criticized the lack of transparency surrounding the partnership, including on who stands to benefit more — Manila or Washington.
“Right now, the lack of transparency and accountability in the whole process, the way dissent is being treated, it raises a lot of red flags, whether this significant investment is actually for us in the Philippines, and who it will benefit in the long run,” he said.
“We haven’t firmed up the details yet, so we don’t really know, but we are quite sure that when it comes to global supply chains, the lack of our national industrialization efforts would always put us on the starting point, which means raw materials and labor, [but] nothing beyond that,” he added.
He stressed the need to ensure that investments translate into long-term and sustainable national development.
Energy and Indigenous rights concerns
Dela Cruz said the initiative could significantly affect energy, water use, agriculture, land use, and the displacement of Indigenous communities.
He called for a whole-of-society approach instead of rushing the project into implementation.
He also questioned the energy plan for the proposed hub, saying energy-intensive industries should be located alongside renewable energy sources.
He warned that current messaging appeared to point toward greater dependence on liquefied natural gas (LNG).
“LNG is not green. Gas will never be green,” he said.
Dela Cruz further cautioned against sidelining Indigenous peoples’ rights and community consultations to speed up implementation.
“It’s almost as if we’re ready to give up on community consultation, just to make sure this is railroaded into implementation,” he said.
Framework deal still unsigned
The Philippines joined the U.S.-led Pax Silica initiative in April.
The initiative seeks to strengthen supply chains for critical minerals, semiconductors, and artificial intelligence technologies.
Under the partnership, the U.S. and Philippine governments also announced plans for a 4,000-acre (1,619-hectare) economic security zone in New Clark City, Capas, Tarlac, within the Luzon Economic Corridor.
The framework agreement for the proposed hub, however, remained unsigned as of Monday.
The Department of Trade and Industry said negotiations were ongoing and that the agreement was still targeted for signing before the end of 2026.
Foreign Affairs Secretary Ma. Theresa Lazaro, meanwhile, declined to confirm on Monday whether it would be signed during U.S. President Donald Trump’s visit to Manila for the 49th ASEAN Summit.
The Department of Environment and Natural Resources said in August that it had not received or processed an environmental impact assessment application for the project and that it had no clear project description at the time.
Human Rights Watch also raised concerns on Monday that the proposed hub could displace Indigenous Aeta communities and farmers in Capas, Tarlac.
The group called on the Philippine government to protect their land rights and livelihoods.
The Marcos administration has said no farmers will be displaced by the project, noting that the site has been designated a buildable zone since 2019.
Comments (0)
LEAVE A REPLY
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!
Related Articles

No brakes: Cielo Magno vows candor in 2028 Senate bid
By Joseph Bernard A. Marzan ILOILO CITY — Former Finance Undersecretary Cielo Magno, an economics professor eyeing a Senate seat in 2028, said Monday, Nov. 16, that she would not change her approach once she formally begins campaigning. Magno and Ronald Llamas, a former political adviser to the late President Benigno Aquino III, met with

‘LOST IN GRAY’: Baronda’s bid to co-author youth code tests City Council’s rules
ILOILO CITY — The Iloilo City Council is grappling with whether Vice Mayor Julie Grace “Love-Love” Baronda can co-author ordinances after it adopted a Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) legal opinion limiting her role in sessions to presiding over proceedings and voting only to break a tie. The

BACK TO BASICS: MORE Power reports zero fatalities, shorter outages after lineman training
ILOILO CITY — MORE Electric and Power Corp. (MORE Power) has sent its linemen back up the poles by hand in a refresher training it links to a year without fatalities and a sharp drop in unscheduled power interruptions. The second batch of the training brought together linemen from MORE
