When dissent does its homework
By Herman M. Lagon
I would normally worry when students walk out of their classes. We spend so much time reminding them to attend lectures, submit requirements, and take their studies seriously. Then, one morning, they leave their classrooms, pick up placards, and join a protest.
And I find myself cheering them on. Well, not entirely. But you get the point.
On Nov. 13, thousands of students from universities across the country joined demonstrations against Pax Silica, the US-led technology initiative, and the anticipated visit of American President Donald Trump. Students from UP, Ateneo, La Salle, UST, PUP, SLU, UB, and other schools took part. Some walked out of classes. Others gathered in the streets. Their messages spread quickly online.
I watched the developments with interest, partly because I have been following the Pax Silica issue myself. I even wrote about it last August, when the proposed technology hub in New Clark City was beginning to attract attention.
My position then was fairly simple. I saw possibilities worth exploring, but I also had questions. I still do.
So, no, I am not entirely on the protesters’ side when they call for Pax Silica’s outright rejection. I would rather see the Philippines negotiate a fair and beneficial arrangement than walk away from a potentially important opportunity. We have enough talented engineers, scientists, researchers, and IT professionals working overseas. If this initiative could help some of them build decent careers here, why wouldn’t we at least examine it seriously?
But I am certainly on the students’ side when they demand answers. And I admire how they have gone about making themselves heard.
Consider what it takes to organize students from different universities, with different schedules, academic pressures, and personal circumstances, around an issue that is hardly easy to explain. Pax Silica is not exactly the kind of topic that comes up during an ordinary barkada conversation. We are talking about semiconductors, AI, international supply chains, foreign investments, ancestral lands, and water and electricity requirements.
Yet these young people managed to bring the discussion beyond policy papers and conference halls. They took it to the streets. And, yes, to Facebook, TikTok, and wherever else their generation happens to gather.
We older people sometimes complain that today’s youth spend too much time on their phones. Well, here they were using those phones to organize, share information, mobilize fellow students, and challenge a major government initiative.
There is something encouraging about that. The concerns themselves are serious. The proposed 1,620-hectare development in New Clark City has raised questions about its possible effects on Aeta communities, farmers, water resources, and electricity supply. Some groups have warned of displacement. Government authorities have disputed certain claims and offered assurances.
Who is telling the fuller story? That is precisely why the public deserves access to the actual plans, agreements, environmental assessments, and consultations. We should not have to choose between believing everything the government says and believing everything its critics say.
We need evidence. And we need people willing to keep asking for it.
I remember writing in my earlier column that the country should aim to become a creator of technology, not merely another place where foreign companies assemble products. That remains my hope. I want our graduates designing chips, developing AI applications, conducting research, and building enterprises that can compete internationally.
But what good would all that be if the communities surrounding these facilities ended up losing their land, water, or livelihood? What kind of progress would that be? These are fair questions, whether they come from an economist, a farmer, an Indigenous leader, or a 19-year-old student carrying a handwritten placard.
Of course, I also hope the protesters take the trouble to study the other side. Not every foreign investment is exploitation. Not every international partnership compromises sovereignty. And not every environmental concern necessarily means a project must be abandoned.
There are details to examine, alternatives to consider, and safeguards to demand. That is where the real work begins.
I would love to see the same students who marched last Friday organize forums, invite experts with differing views, examine government documents, and prepare their own policy recommendations. Let them challenge officials with well-researched questions. Let them question investors about technology transfer, environmental safeguards, employment commitments, and the rights of affected communities.
And let them listen, too. Listening is not surrendering one’s position. Sometimes it is how we discover that our first position needs improving.
I say this as someone who has spent a good part of his life in classrooms and in the streets. Students can be wonderfully certain of themselves. So can teachers, for that matter. Age does not automatically make our opinions wiser. Neither does youth make an argument more truthful. We all need the humility to admit when we have missed something.
What troubles me more than the students’ opposition to Pax Silica is the possibility that their concerns will be dismissed simply because they are young, idealistic, or supposedly influenced by one political group or another.
That would be a mistake. Young people have every right to care about decisions whose consequences they may live with much longer than the officials making them.
And if they sometimes sound impatient, perhaps we should remember how many promises their generation has already inherited. Better jobs. Better schools. Better public services. Less corruption. A more livable environment. They have heard these promises for years.
Now they want to know what is actually being done. I also hope their activism does not end with Pax Silica.
There are plenty of other issues that deserve this kind of energy. Public funds that disappear into questionable projects. Classrooms that remain unfinished. Farmers who struggle despite producing our food. Public hospitals that cannot adequately serve their patients. Political dynasties that seem almost impossible to dislodge. Communities whose concerns are heard only when an election approaches.
Imagine if even a portion of the energy we saw during these demonstrations could be sustained across such issues. Not necessarily through more walkouts. There are other ways to make a difference.
Students can investigate, write, volunteer, organize community discussions, attend public consultations, and help people understand policies that affect their lives. They can support honest candidates and question dishonest ones. They can learn how government actually works, including the less exciting parts involving budgets, procurement, ordinances, and accountability reports.
It is not glamorous work. It seldom goes viral. But it matters.
And perhaps that is what excites me most about what happened last Friday. Not the slogans themselves, and certainly not the disruption of classes. It is the possibility that these young Filipinos are discovering what collective action can accomplish.
They may not always agree with one another. Some may eventually change their minds about Pax Silica. Others may become even more convinced that it should be rejected.
That’s fine. I would worry more if they stopped caring altogether.
For my part, I remain open to Pax Silica, provided our government can demonstrate that the arrangement is transparent, fair, environmentally responsible, and genuinely protective of Philippine sovereignty and the rights of our people, especially Indigenous communities and those whose livelihoods may be affected.
I want the promised opportunities. I also want the safeguards. Surely, we can ask for both.
And while I may disagree with the students on what should ultimately happen to Pax Silica, I am glad they are making themselves heard. They have reminded us that young people are not merely waiting for their turn to inherit this country. They already have a stake in it.
I just hope that when the placards are put away and the excitement has faded, they will keep reading, questioning, organizing, and showing up for causes that may not attract as much attention.
The streets can teach important lessons. So can classrooms. The real achievement would be to bring what we learn from one into the other.
And perhaps, years from now, some of these students will find themselves in positions where they can actually change the policies they once protested.
I hope they remember how it felt to be on the other side of the table. More importantly, I hope they remember to listen.
***
Doc H fondly describes himself as a “student of and for life” who, like many others, aspires to a life-giving and why-driven world grounded in social justice and the pursuit of happiness. His views do not necessarily reflect those of the institutions where he is employed or with which he is connected.
Comments (0)
LEAVE A REPLY
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!
Related Articles

Metro Iloilo’s flood-drought paradox
On August 17, 2026, around 165 millimeters of rain fell on Iloilo City in six hours, putting 65 barangays underwater. Families spent the night hoisting refrigerators onto concrete blocks while brown water crept up the stairs. Wait until April 2027, as those same families will be lining up with plastic jerrycans, buying overpriced water from private delivery trucks because the

Kucho-Kucho and Iloilo’s fading optimism
There was a time when Ilonggos seemed to speak about their city with a special kind of optimism. It was not optimism supplied by speeches or glossy brochures. They could see things happening: investments arriving, businesses opening, familiar places changing, possibilities expanding. The talk was often about what was coming next. Even the habitual critics

A national call for an all-Pinoy bookstore
There is nothing wrong with dreaming. In fact, some of the most meaningful changes in society begin with an idea that people are willing to pursue collectively. But there are moments when dreaming must go beyond personal aspirations and become a public conversation, a collective demand, and ultimately, a concrete
