Tulfo slams Sara Duterte defense for ‘weak’ impeachment witnesses
PASAY CITY — Sen. Erwin Tulfo called out Vice President Sara Duterte’s defense team on Thursday, Nov. 19, for fielding weak witnesses after its latest expert admitted he had challenged the prosecution’s forensic findings without reading the full report or any of its attachments.
Under questioning by senator-judges on Day 44 of the impeachment trial, lawyer Rainer Dela Fuente, who previously worked at the Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) Secretariat, acknowledged that he had taken the stand without reading those documents.
“Mahina po yung witnesses that you’re presenting here these past few days. Get somebody who can really stand up, who can really answer questions from the senator-judges,” Erwin Tulfo told the defense panel.
Dela Fuente is the latest in a string of defense witnesses who struggled to answer critical questions, failed to produce supporting documents, or made admissions that raised further questions about Duterte’s alleged undeclared assets and unexplained wealth.
His testimony was meant to counter the lone remaining charge against Duterte. The House prosecution panel earlier withdrew three of the four articles of impeachment, leaving the allegations of unexplained wealth and nondisclosure of assets under Article II.
Documents never seen
When Sen. Bam Aquino asked whether he had received copies of AMLC records, bank statements, insurance placements, and the General Information Sheets (GIS) of Duterte’s companies, Dela Fuente repeatedly answered, “None, Your Honor.”
Defense counsel Mark Vinluan himself confirmed that the defense panel had not given Dela Fuente a copy of the forensic report, which puzzled Sen. Joel Villanueva.
“If he is to refute the report, then he should have seen the report, should have read the report,” Villanueva said. “Now if he cannot answer these questions then, for me, it’s going to be useless.”
Dela Fuente also admitted to Sen. Risa Hontiveros that he had not read the entire forensic report of the prosecution’s expert witness, lawyer Alexander Cabrera.
Erwin Tulfo said Dela Fuente’s testimony amounted to mere theory, since he had not examined a single document.
“Kung hindi naman niya po nakita pala ay mga dokumento, STRs (Suspicious Transaction Reports), CTRs (Covered Transaction Reports), what good is it? Para anong titistigo niya, e puro ito theory sa kanyang paningin, sa kanyang paniniwala,” he said.
Sen. Raffy Tulfo questioned how Dela Fuente could refute the analysis of Cabrera, a forensic financial expert, when he had not even seen the full report.
“Kung ire-refute niya ang forensic expert witness and yet hindi pala siya nabigyan ng kopya nung mga dokumento na prinesent ng expert witness, so hindi dapat siya pwedeng mag-refute o kumontra dahil in the first place, wala siyang idea kung ano ‘yung mga nakasaad dun sa sinabi ng testigo,” Raffy Tulfo said.
He added that Dela Fuente, a former Bank Officer II at the AMLC, had no basis to contradict Cabrera’s forensic report.
“Wala siyang kaalam-alam, Mr. Presiding Officer. Wala talaga. Zero,” Raffy Tulfo said.
‘Super witness’
Raffy Tulfo also took issue with the broad range of questions the defense put to Dela Fuente, who was originally presented to explain fundamental concepts relating to anti-money laundering.
The witness was later asked for his opinions on matters relating to the impeachment proceedings, constitutional law, theological topics, and even the price of a luxury vehicle.
“Is he a super witness, omni-witness? Ano bang klaseng witness ‘tong prine-present ng defense? Pati ba naman amici curiae papakialamanan niya, Supreme Court pakialamanan niya, Ombudsman, DOJ?” Raffy Tulfo asked.
He continued, “Who is he? Who is this guy? I’m really very, very curious about the qualifications of the gentleman para lahat na lang topic kayang-kaya niya sagutin mula sa defense.”
Visibly frustrated, Raffy Tulfo asked Presiding Officer Francis Escudero to put the witness “on a short leash.”
“Parang nakaka-antok na. Parang hindi kapani-paniwala. Parang binobola lang tayo,” he said.
Villanueva echoed concerns about the scope of the testimony, noting that Dela Fuente had been subpoenaed to discuss fundamental anti-money laundering concepts, not to address every legal question arising from the impeachment proceedings.
Dela Fuente said he spent 24 months in an entry-level position at the AMLC Secretariat. He also said he worked at Punongbayan for only two months before setting up his own practice.
String of defense setbacks
Dela Fuente’s testimony was the latest in a series of courtroom setbacks for the defense since it began presenting witnesses on Nov. 9.
Its first witness, Davao City Assessor Jaime Adalin, drew criticism from senator-judges after giving shifting answers about a trip to China.
Adalin initially could not recall the trip, then suggested he could not remember its date, prompting Erwin Tulfo to warn him about the seriousness of testifying under oath.
The following day, Samal City Assessor John Kenneth Enumerables admitted he could not establish with certainty that a property registered under Duterte’s husband, lawyer Manases “Mans” Carpio, was the same property declared in the Vice President’s Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth (SALN).
On Nov. 11, GenCorp Industries Inc. corporate counsel Suzette Balucanag-Punay confirmed that Duterte received PHP 2.14 million in payments from the company between 2022 and 2025, supposedly representing a return of capital.
However, Balucanag-Punay admitted that she could not produce verifiable records establishing the amount of Duterte’s original investment.
The defense suffered another evidentiary setback the following day when lawyer Anel Martin Antero, a friend of Carpio, testified that he had reimbursed part of a PHP 205,007 restaurant bill charged to Carpio’s credit card during a dinner in Tokyo, Japan.
Under cross-examination, however, Antero admitted having no documentary proof of the alleged reimbursement.
The successive testimonies have led House prosecution spokespersons to remark that the defense has yet to substantially disprove the financial records and findings presented during the prosecution’s case.
At the center of those findings is the forensic examination of Cabrera, an accountant and lawyer who has served as chairman emeritus of PwC Philippines, which identified at least PHP 817.87 million in allegedly unexplained wealth, undeclared assets, and income involving Duterte and Carpio from 2022 to 2025.
What is at stake
Escudero said in October that the trial could conclude before the end of 2026.
Under the 1987 Constitution, a conviction requires the votes of two-thirds of all members of the Senate, or 16 of the 24 senators.
A guilty verdict would remove Duterte from office and could end her bid for the presidency in 2028.
Comments (0)
LEAVE A REPLY
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!
Related Articles

180 Iloilo City barangays urged to form animal welfare committees
ILOILO CITY — The Iloilo City Council is urging all 180 barangays to immediately establish and operationalize their Barangay Animal Welfare Committees to strengthen grassroots efforts against animal cruelty, neglect, and irresponsible pet ownership. The council on Thursday, Nov. 19, unanimously approved the resolution of Councilor Johnny Young, chairperson of the

E. COLI DETECTED: Iloilo City Hall steps up testing after 3 contaminated wells found
ILOILO CITY — At least three shallow wells in Iloilo City have been found contaminated, prompting the city government to intensify its monitoring and testing of shallow water sources, the General Services Office (GSO) said. GSO head Neil Ravena confirmed to Daily Guardian on Thursday, Nov. 19, that the contaminated wells

GEN Z LEADS PUSH: 3 in 5 Filipinos back anti-political dynasty law, survey finds
Three in five Filipinos (60%) believe that Congress should pass a law prohibiting or limiting political dynasties, while a third (33%) oppose the proposed legislation, the October 2026 National Momentum Survey of Momentum Research found. The remaining 8% said they were unsure or refused to answer. The renewed attention on
