Tingi-tingi cigarettes: Public health, poverty, and the right to choose
We learned of Iloilo City’s impending restriction on selling cigarettes by the stick from Manang Lorna, a sari-sari store owner somewhere in the city.
“‘To, bawal na kuno mag baligya sang tingi nga sigarilyo sa January 1 hambal sa naglibot nga ICAST. May penalty kuno kon madakpan.”
She said personnel from the Iloilo City Anti-Smoking Task Force (ICAST) had visited stores to announce that tingi-tingi cigarette sales would be prohibited beginning January 1, 2027. Her tone was resigned, with an undercurrent of opposition. “May warning man na siguro,” she added, suggesting that she might continue selling individual sticks, at least until warned.
We support the restriction. It is a justified public-health measure, especially because selling cigarettes by the stick makes smoking more accessible to young people. Its costs to some customers and sari-sari stores are real, but they do not outweigh the expected public benefit.
A child who cannot afford a pack may still be able to buy a cigarette. Individual sticks also reach buyers without the health warnings printed on packs. Recognizing this problem, Article 16 of the World Health Organization’s Framework Convention on Tobacco Control calls on countries to work toward prohibiting individual cigarette sales. The objective is not simply to inconvenience smokers. It is to reduce access to an addictive product before experimentation becomes dependence.
The objection that the restriction is anti-poor cannot simply be brushed aside. Tingi-tingi is how many households manage scarce cash. People buy coffee, cooking oil, and other necessities in small amounts because that is what they can afford. Requiring a full pack raises the minimum amount needed to buy cigarettes, a constraint wealthier smokers may scarcely notice. Store owners who depend on frequent small transactions may also lose some income.
Yet a burden that falls more heavily on the poor is not necessarily a policy against their welfare. Tobacco spending competes with food, transport, and children’s needs. Smoking-related illness can impose medical bills and lost earnings on families least able to absorb them. If the restriction discourages young people from starting and helps some adults smoke less, poorer households stand to gain in health and disposable income. Those longer-term benefits belong in the assessment alongside today’s inconvenience.
There is also the right-to-choose objection. Adults may legally smoke, and personal freedom has value even when choices carry health risks. Iloilo City, however, is not banning adult smoking or cigarette purchases. It is restricting one method of selling a product whose accessibility has consequences beyond an individual transaction, particularly for minors. The restriction is narrower than a prohibition on tobacco use.
Public policies routinely have winners and losers. The proper test is not whether anyone is inconvenienced, but whether the expected public benefit justifies the burden and whether the rule is lawful and proportionate. On those grounds, the city has a credible case. That does not excuse poor implementation: ICAST should clearly state the legal basis and penalties, apply the rule consistently to small and large sellers, and judge success by changes in smoking initiation and consumption, not the number of sari-sari stores cited.
What stays with us, however, is Manang Lorna’s explanation for wanting to keep selling individual cigarettes: “Kalulu-oy man mga imol nga indi ka sarang sang isa ka pack”.
Her compassion is genuine. She sees customers who arrive with only enough money for a stick or two, and refusing them feels unkind. She is responding to poverty as she encounters it across her counter, one small purchase at a time.
Yet we must ask: does making cigarettes affordable to the poor actually help the poor? The same customers she worries about must stretch their money for meals, electricity, transport, and their children’s needs. A few pesos daily become a persistent expense; addiction and illness can exact a much greater cost. Making a harmful product easier to buy is not necessarily an act that improves the buyer’s welfare.
Manang Lorna’s concern deserves respect. The city should take the people behind that concern seriously, even as it pursues the public-health benefit. Protecting the poor means more than preserving their ability to buy cigarettes one stick at a time. It also means preventing tobacco dependence from taking more of their money, their health, and their future.
Comments (0)
LEAVE A REPLY
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!
Related Articles

Making inclusion truly work
A child with autism enters a regular Grade 4 classroom. The school has accepted him, his name is on the class list, and there is a chair waiting. On paper, inclusion has happened. Then Mathematics begins. The room gets noisy. The child becomes overwhelmed. The teacher has 44 other pupils, two

Sustaining Western Visayas agri-fisheries, health, and ecosystems against El Niño
Agricultural Drought and Water Management Western Visayas experiences recurring El Niño dry spells every three to six years. DOST-PAGASA and the Regional Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council Region 6 track an intensifying drought unfolding across three distinct phases. Phase one brings severe rainfall deficits from October to November across Panay and

Patience in life
Patience is the active discipline and inner strength to wait, endure, and persist through delays and challenges or in pursuit of goals without anger or frustration. Far from being a passive weakness, it acts as a vital bridge between effort and results. Patience is the conscious, learned ability to remain calm, resilient,
