Scientists Confirm Two Domesticated Buffalo Species in PH

By Eunice Jean Patron

Domesticated buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis) in the country have traditionally been classified into two subspecies: swamp buffaloes and riverine buffaloes. A recent study, however, provides evidence that these two are not subspecies, but are instead distinct from each other.

Swamp buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis carabanensis) are primarily used to assist farmers with tilling the land, transporting tools, and, alternatively, for meat, milk, hide, and manure, which is used as organic fertilizer. Riverine buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis bubalis), on the other hand, are mainly used in milk production. In the Philippines, crossbreeding and backcrossing these two breeds on a large scale helps create animals with improved potential for milk and meat production, despite their differences. Hybridization of swamp and river buffaloes has limited success, sometimes producing viable offspring that don’t achieve the desired traits.

A team of researchers conducted an investigation to clarify the taxonomic designation of swamp and riverine buffaloes in the Philippines. They discovered that the DNA sequences of the genes from both swamp and riverine buffaloes are distinguishable and that their chromosome numbers are different, affirming that they are two distinct species, not just subspecies of Bubalus bubalis.

The research team is comprised of Dr. Ian Kendrich C. Fontanilla, Nelvie Fatima Jane A. Soliven, John Gregor A. Roño, Francis L. Fontanilla, Emerson R. Servo, and Dr. Ernelea P. Cao of the University of the Philippines – Diliman College of Science’s Institute of Biology (UPD-CS IB) and Dr. Lilian P. Villamor, Therese Patricka C. Cailipan, Alexander M. Paraguas, and Aivhie Jhoy E. Cuanang from the Department of Agriculture – Philippine Carabao Center (DA-PCC).

“These results corroborate the observed differences in their appearances. Swamp buffaloes can be identified by the white or light gray markings on their lower jaw and brisket, known as a chevron, as well as their lighter skin and coat color compared to riverine buffaloes. They are also smaller, weighing between 325 and 450 kg, and have crescent-shaped horns. They are mainly used as draught animals,” said Dr. Villamor, citing data from her previous studies on buffaloes. “River buffaloes, on the other hand, are larger, weighing between 450 and 1,000 kg, and have curly horns. They are primarily raised for milk and meat production.”

According to the team, the Philippine native carabao, which is currently classified as Bubalus bubalis carabanensis, should be now considered as Bubalus kerabau Fitzinger, 1860. “The reclassification of the Bubalus bubalis carabanensis to Bubalus kerabau Fitzinger, 1860 supports earlier assumptions that riverine and swamp buffaloes are distinct,” added Dr. Fontanilla. “Confusions on the classifications of the two buffaloes have implications on the breeding program of these species.”

As their study was limited to examining the chromosomes of only swamp and riverine buffaloes, the researchers plan to include chromosomes from crossbred buffaloes in future studies to gain new insights into how these different types of buffaloes are genetically related and potentially improve the classification of the Bubalus bubalis.

The study, titled “Molecular Data and Karyotype Revealed Two Distinct Species of Domesticated Water Buffaloes in the Philippines,” offers valuable insights into the diversity of domesticated buffaloes, and can guide conservation and management efforts, particularly in developing potential hybrids with desired traits. It was published in the Philippine Journal of Science, an open-access, single-blind peer-reviewed journal on natural sciences, engineering, mathematics, and social sciences.

References:

Cailipan, T. P., Paraguas, A., Cuanang, A. J., Soliven, N. F., Roño, J. G., Fontanilla, F., Servo, E., Cao, E., Fontanilla, I. K., & Villamor, L. (2023). Molecular data and karyotype revealed two distinct species of domesticated water buffaloes in the Philippines. Philippine Journal of Science, 152(5). https://doi.org/10.56899/152.05.27

Cailipan, T.P.C., Villamor, L.P. 2021.  Molecular characterization of SRY gene in the Philippine Carabao (Bubalus bubalis) swamp buffalo populations. SciEnggJ 14(2):291-296.

Ruane, J., Mba, C., Boettcher, P., Koskela, J., Mair, G., & Ramasamy, S. (2023). Case studies of the use of agricultural biotechnologies to meet the needs of smallholders in developing countries. Food & Agriculture Org.

Villamor, L.P., Takahashi, Y., Nomura, K. and Amano T. 2021. Genetic diversity of Philippine Carabao (Bubalus bubalis) using mitochondrial DNA D-loop variation: implications to conservation and management. Philippine Journal of Science, 150(3): 837-846.