Regional wages have had their day
By Herman M. Lagon
Buy a kilo of rice in Iloilo and tell the cashier you earn a provincial wage. See if you get a provincial discount. Try the same experiment with gasoline, medicine, mobile data, school supplies, or a replacement phone charger. Perhaps ask the electric cooperative whether your bill can be adjusted because Manila workers earn more. We already know how that conversation ends. Geography matters to the cost of living, certainly. But it does not magically make the ordinary needs of a worker in the province inexpensive.
Maybe it is time to retire the regional wage boards. They were created in 1989 because regions differed in living costs, productivity, jobs, and businesses’ capacity to pay. That made sense. But what made sense then deserves another look now.
Today, NCR’s minimum wage is PHP 718 to PHP 755 a day. Here in Western Visayas, it is PHP 520 to PHP 550; in the Cordillera, PHP 505. Of course, regional economies differ. Still, we have to ask: Should where a Filipino lives make this much difference in what a day’s work is worth?
Think of two security guards working through midnight, or two supermarket workers stocking the same products. One works in Manila, the other in Iloilo. Both get tired. Both go home to bills. But the law puts very different floors beneath their pay. Both buy rice. Both have children who need notebooks. Both occasionally stare at a pharmacy receipt and wonder which expense can wait until payday. Yet the law permits their minimum economic worth to differ substantially because one reports for work on the other side of an administrative boundary. Labor groups have challenged this arrangement for years, arguing that regionalization institutionalizes unequal treatment and has failed to deliver adequate wages.
The argument for regional wages, however, cannot simply be laughed out of the room. Businesses are correct about one important thing: Manila is not Miagao, and Makati is not a fourth-class municipality. Rent, land, customer volume, transport, supply chains, productivity, and purchasing power vary enormously. A large corporation with branches nationwide does not face the same circumstances as a family-run bakery employing six people in a provincial town. Employer organizations argue that regional boards allow wages to reflect these differences and protect enterprises, particularly micro, small, and medium businesses, from increases they cannot absorb. That concern deserves more than the usual social-media reply of “Kung hindi kayang magpasahod, magsara.”
Closing businesses does not feed workers either.
But that is an argument for a careful transition, not necessarily for preserving regional wage inequality indefinitely. House Bill No. 8081 offers one direction: a national minimum-wage system emerging from consolidated proposals in the House, including a measure that envisioned phasing out regional rates while providing wage support for sensitive sectors. This is where reform becomes more intelligent than simply declaring one number on Monday and expecting every employer from Batanes to Tawi-Tawi to find the money by Tuesday.
A national floor could be phased in, with serious transition assistance for genuinely vulnerable MSMEs and sectors rather than permanent cheap labor as their unofficial subsidy. Government has many ways to help small businesses cope with higher wages — tax relief, affordable loans, better infrastructure, cheaper electricity, technology support, and temporary wage assistance. If a small provincial business is worth keeping but needs time to adjust, then help it become stronger. The answer cannot always be asking its workers to make do with less.
Regional wages were also supposed to bring more industries and jobs to the provinces. Yet many workers still leave home because better opportunities remain concentrated in the cities. That should tell us something. Cheap workers do not create strong local economies. Good roads, reliable power, skilled people, internet, customers, safety, and dependable government do. A province should attract investment because it is a good place to do business, not primarily because its people are cheaper to hire.
Still, a national minimum wage should not be mistaken for a national living wage by magic. That distinction matters. Raising the statutory floor will not solve contractualization, informality, underemployment, low productivity, weak industries, or the problems faced by the millions of workers outside effective minimum-wage protection. The material supplied for this column cites PSA data showing that 7.9 million employed Filipinos wanted additional work or longer hours in April 2025. A worker with a better legal wage but only three days of work a week can remain poor. Wage reform therefore has to travel with job creation, industrial development, stronger agriculture, skills development, social protection, and support for local enterprise.
This is also why I hesitate when the debate becomes a shouting match between “greedy employers” and “entitled workers.” Most people I know do not fit comfortably into either cartoon. The small restaurant owner worries about payroll on Friday. The waiter worries about groceries on Saturday. The private-school administrator worries about keeping tuition affordable; the maintenance worker worries about sending his own child to school. Their anxieties are different, but they are real. Good policy has to look at both faces across the table while remembering that the worker usually has less room to absorb the shock.
Thirty-seven years is long enough to examine an experiment without insulting the people who designed it. RA 6727 belonged to a particular economic moment. Even today, the government maintains that regional boards can tailor adjustments to prevailing local economic conditions, which is the strongest argument for keeping them. But institutions are tools, not heirlooms. When circumstances change, we are allowed to ask whether an old mechanism still produces a fair result.
I would rather see one national wage floor, introduced responsibly, periodically reviewed, and accompanied by targeted help for enterprises and sectors that genuinely need time to adjust. Regional economic differences can still inform development policy, incentives, productivity programs, and government assistance. They need not permanently determine how little a Filipino worker may legally be paid.
Because when the cashier totals the rice, sardines, medicine, electricity, school allowance, and fare at the end of the month, the bill does not ask whether the worker came from NCR or Region VI. It simply asks to be paid.
Perhaps after nearly four decades, our wage policy should finally say the same thing about the worker.
***
Doc H fondly describes himself as a “student of and for life” who, like many others, aspires to a life-giving and why-driven world grounded in social justice and the pursuit of happiness. His views do not necessarily reflect those of the institutions with which he is employed or connected.
Comments (0)
LEAVE A REPLY
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!
Related Articles

Paper tigers
Another ministerial summit wraps up in Manila with a fresh round of applause. It has been two years since 130 countries met in Bogotá and left with 120 concrete pledges to protect children. You almost want to believe the promises this time, until you look at the numbers. According to UNICEF, more than 370 million girls and

BenCab between early and late style
The exhibition “In Honor of Form,” presented by Gajah Gallery Manila, foregrounds the sculptural practice of National Artist Benedicto “BenCab” Cabrera. Curated by veteran museum professional Dannie R. Alvarez, it brings together ten bronze works developed between 2023 and 2026 in collaboration with Yogya Art Lab (YAL) in Yogyakarta, Indonesia. The

Are we under attack?
“As soon as the fear approaches near, attack and destroy it.” – Chanakya WE feared the worst in the United States over the weekend amid massive glitches and outages that caught many Americans by surprise across all 50 states and U.S. territories. In case of a radioactive attack, we have been
