PIDS study reveals serious school infra gaps in PH’s basic educ sector

A recent study by state think tank Philippine Institute for Development Studies (PIDS) found gaps in the country’s school infrastructure, highlighting the need for more investments.

The author, PIDS Senior Research Fellow Adoracion Navarro, assessed the adequacy of school infrastructure in the country’s basic education sector in terms of the adequacy of classrooms; access to water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH) facilities; electricity access; and information and communications technology (ICT) access.

In terms of adequacy of classrooms, the study found that while there had been progress in decongesting schools at the national level, spatial inequality in regional classroom-student ratios still exists.

Recent data from the Department of Education (DepEd) showed that classroom-student ratios for various levels in the National Capital Region, Region IV-A, Region XI, and the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao are higher than the 1:40 classroom-student target ratio set by the Philippine Development Plan (PDP) 2017-2022. According to Navarro, this indicated classroom congestion in these regions.

“Achieving the PDP targets on classroom-student ratios at the national level should leave no room for complacency. The Philippine government still needs to monitor the emergence of classroom shortages,” Navarro said.

As for WASH facilities, the country lagged behind its neighboring countries and Southeast Asian countries with lower per capita income, such as Myanmar, Cambodia, and Timor-Leste.

“There is no readily available data on countries’ annual expenditure for WASH facilities, but the results suggest that the Philippines has not been investing enough in WASH facilities compared with its Southeast Asian peers that have lower per capita income,” Navarro pointed out.

The study also found that access to electricity in Philippine schools needs improvement, noting that while other countries in the East and Southeast Asian regions “have already achieved universal access” to electricity, the Philippines “still struggles to complete the electrification of schools”.

“This challenge is compounded by the need to upgrade the electricity connections of schools to stabilize electricity current fluctuations and meet digital learning requirements,” Navarro said, adding that this problem exacerbated the digital divide in schools.

According to 2020 data from DepEd, 1,562 schools still had no electricity connection, and 39,335 schools needed upgrading of their electrical connections.

Gaps in ICT access, particularly in terms of unmet delivery targets for computer package—the focus of the ICT developmental objective in the Philippine basic education sector—were also found in the study.

“Philippine schools have low computer and internet access rates, unlike those in many neighboring countries which had already achieved universal access to computers and internet for their schools,” Navarro said.

The COVID-19 pandemic also highlighted other areas that must be prioritized, including good ventilation, improved WASH facilities to support disinfection and disease transmission prevention, and adequate ICT infrastructure to help adapt to new modes of learning.

To help address these gaps, Navarro emphasized the importance of a geographic information system-based monitoring of school infrastructure vis-à-vis spending, results, outcomes, and gaps.

The study also mentioned the Special Education Fund as one source of funding for school infrastructure investment. According to Navarro, expanding its expense items coverage will “engage more local government units to accelerate public sector investments on school infrastructure”.

The government may also explore public-private partnerships to accelerate investments in school infrastructure, but lessons from previous implementation experiences should be considered.

“It cannot be overemphasized that both the public and private sectors must assume responsibility in improving the students’ learning environment through better and adequate school infrastructure,” Navarro said.

(This report is based on the PIDS discussion paper titled “School Infrastructure in the Philippines: Where Are We Now and Where Should We Be Heading?”)