[Misleading] Blue: Favorite color of people with mental health issues?
By AIRA GRACE MARIE P. FERRER (Contributor)
University of Santo Tomas
A viral claim that is reviving a 1931 scientific result said that blue is the favorite color of people with mental health issues (including psychopaths). This type of claim seems common in pop psychology and continues to spread through social media and other media platforms as misinformation.
This misleading claim may have originated from a 1931 paper by Siegfried Katz, titled Colour Preference in the Insane, published in the former Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology. [The current name of the journal is the Journal of Psychopathology and Clinical Science]
The paper carried out an experiment to 433 patients at the Hudson River State Hospital in the United States. Katz used six “spectral colors”: red, orange, yellow, green, blue and violet. Blue turned out as the “most pleasing color” to 40.9 percent of males and 40.4 percent of females of all ages.
Blue was the most pleasing color to the total number of patients of all ages and both sexes, 40.9 per cent of males and 40.4 per cent of females giving first preference to this color.
Katz then determined the influence of age “upon the preferences of the insane” by dividing respondents into three groups: below-25 years old, between 25 and 46 years old, and 46 years old and above. More males under-25 years preferred blue (60 percent). But as age advanced, the “percentage of choice for blue decreased”.
- 25-to-46 group: 45 percent for males and 39 percent for females; and
- 46 and above: 37 percent apiece for males and females.
While such study results came out 95 years ago, years of research have challenged this 1931 paper. A 2010 paper by Helen Carruthers and colleagues examined color choices among healthy individuals and those experiencing anxiety or depression, demonstrating that color associations and preferences are different across these groups. Their findings do not establish blue as an indicator of mental illness or psychopathic traits.
The linking of color and diagnosed mental issues saw others chime in.
A Filipino registered psychometrician, Ms. Faith Bagnes, even thinks the claim is “inaccurate and might not be proven scientifically, as it is generalized and have poor basis of being evaluated.”
Bagnes also disagrees with some people’s insinuation that that having blue as a preferred color automatically indicates mental illness or psychopathic traits. She also does not recommend using color preferences as a diagnostic basis.
Additionally, media organizations such as Brin have posted about this specific claim on Instagram, emphasizing that linking particular colors to specific mental health diagnoses is not supported by established psychiatric research.
In the months of September, October and November, the Facebook post “Mind Box” made social media cards about this claim and used its page to explain such a scientific observation.
Comments on Mind Box’s September 26 post, titled “The Surprising Link Between Mental Health and Color Preferences,” seem to suggest that people may readily believe such claims and have begun relating them to their own color preferences. That is even if Mind Box made explanations already.
“People with mental health issues, including psychopathy, often claim that their favorite color is blue. This is not just a random observation, studies suggest that color choices can reflect aspects of a person’s emotional state and psychological tendencies,” Mind Box wrote.
The Facebook page owner explains: “Blue is often associated with calmness, stability, and tranquility. For those who struggle with emotional regulation or empathy, blue may represent an idealized sense of control and detachment. It’s a color that feels safe, structured, and non-threatening, qualities that may resonate with individuals seeking to avoid emotional vulnerability or confrontation.”
But given that blue is “a calming color,” Mind Box avers that individuals with psychopathic traits who prefer blue “raises questions about emotional distancing”.
“Psychopaths, who often lack emotional depth and empathy, may be drawn to blue because of its cool, controlled associations,” Mind Box wrote. “This doesn’t mean that everyone who likes blue has a mental disorder, but it can serve as a fascinating clue in understanding how color and psychology are intertwined.”
Mind Box even gave its post’s readers a word of advice: “Next time you encounter someone’s favorite color, remember, there’s often more beneath the surface.”
References
Katz, S. E.. (1931). Color preference in the insane. The Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 26(2), 203–211. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0072071
Frances Bagnes. Personal interview.
Mind Box (2026, September 26). “The Surprising Link Between Mental Health and Color Preferences.” https://www.facebook.com/MinddBox/posts/the-surprising-link-between-mental-health-and-color-preferencesresearch-in-psych/1378738211981149/
Carruthers, H.R., Morris, J., Tarrier, N. et al. (2010). The Manchester Color Wheel: development of a novel way of identifying color choice and its validation in healthy, anxious and depressed individuals. BMC Medical Research Methodology, 10(12). https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2288-10-12a
Aira Gace Marie P. Ferrer is a graduating BS in Chemical Engineering student of the University of Santo Tomas. She wrote this piece as a requirement for her elective course Fact Checking, Verification and Digital Literacy this first term of Academic Year 2026-2027. UST’s Department of Journalism is offering the said course, targeting non-journalism students.
Comments (0)
LEAVE A REPLY
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!
Related Articles
![[False, image manipulated] Davao City Mayor Baste Duterte ‘finally comes out of closet’](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fold.dailyguardian.com.ph%2Fwp-content%2Fuploads%2F2026%2F11%2FDavao-City-Mayor-Baste-Duterte-finally-comes-out-of-closet.jpg&w=1920&q=75)
[False, image manipulated] Davao City Mayor Baste Duterte ‘finally comes out of closet’
By KRISTINE BERNADETTE B. GANIGAN (Contributor) University of Santo Tomas Various social media posts mocked Mayor Baste Duterte and Senator Robin Padilla after the two figures expressed their support to one another following developments surrounding the Impeachment Trials of Vice President Sara Duterte, the former’s sister. A Facebook parody page, “Congressman Martin Negafuerta,” posted a
![[Misleading] New, improved ‘prediction model’ for earthquakes can predict tremors and their dates](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fold.dailyguardian.com.ph%2Fwp-content%2Fuploads%2F2026%2F11%2FNew-improved-prediction-model-for-earthquakes-can-predict-tremors-and-their-dates.jpg&w=1920&q=75)
[Misleading] New, improved ‘prediction model’ for earthquakes can predict tremors and their dates
By MACK LORENZ D. BERNARDO (Contributor) University of Santo Tomas The Facebook page Manila, Philippines Panganib sa Lindol claimed this: “A newly improved earthquake prediction model indicates a probability as high as 95% of a major earthquake occurring in certain parts of the Philippines within 36 hours, on Monday, October 5, 2026.” This claim is
![[Misleading] Gov’t to sell Mile Long property for P12.26 B](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fold.dailyguardian.com.ph%2Fwp-content%2Fuploads%2F2026%2F11%2FGovt-to-sell-Mile-Long-property-for-P12B.jpg&w=1920&q=75)
[Misleading] Gov’t to sell Mile Long property for P12.26 B
By MACREUBEN E. ALOIT (Contributor) University of Santo Tomas A recent post made by Historya Channel —”Mile Long Property na Pag-aari ng Gobyerno, Ibebenta sa Halagang P12.2 Bilyon Para Makalipon ng Karagdagang Pondo”— has gone viral and had garnered over-28,000 likes and around 4,000 shares. The Facebook post claims that current Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos
