Assigned but not aligned
By Herman M. Lagon
Somewhere tonight, a teacher is studying tomorrow’s lesson almost as hard as her students will. Maybe she majored in Filipino, but Values Education somehow found its way into her teaching load. So she reads. She searches online. She messages a colleague who knows the subject better. Maybe she watches a video or two before calling it a night. Teachers know how this happens. Sometimes the explanation in the faculty room is no more complicated than, “Ikaw na lang anay. Kaya mo na na.” And, well, the teacher usually does.
Maybe that is why we hardly notice the problem anymore. The numbers should make us notice. Among high school teachers in the data, 98 percent of those teaching Physical Sciences were not matched by specialization. In ESP/Values Education, it was 94 percent; Biological Sciences, 80 percent; and Agriculture and Fisheries and MAPEH, 70 percent each. EDCOM II also reported that 62 percent of public high school teachers were handling subjects they did not major in during college. This is not one troublesome subject hidden somewhere in the class program. It is happening across the curriculum. We have become so used to teachers adjusting that sometimes we mistake adjustment for a system that is working.
I am a little careful with the word “mismatched.” It can sound as if we are saying something is wrong with the teacher. We are not. Give a Math major Araling Panlipunan and that teacher may study hard, sit down with an AP colleague, attend training, and eventually become very good at it. I have been around teachers long enough to know that what appears on a transcript is hardly the end of what a teacher can learn. It should not be.
Still, being able to learn something is different from being prepared to teach it. A PIDS study found that 42.86 percent of teachers surveyed were teaching outside their pre-service specialization. Another 31.84 percent handled both matched and mismatched subjects. Only 25.31 percent taught entirely within their specialization. For those working outside their fields, the experience was familiar: more preparation, less confidence, and more difficulty dealing with student misconceptions. If you have ever had to study at night what you are expected to explain the next morning, you know the feeling.
Values Education is a curious example. We sometimes act as though anyone with good values can teach Values Education. Sana ganoon lang kasimple. Students do not come to class asking only what honesty or respect means. They bring questions about friendships, family, choices, responsibility, dignity, citizenship, and all the confusing things that come with growing up. Sometimes two perfectly good values even pull in opposite directions. Guiding students through the difficult work of discernment is precisely where specialized preparation matters. A list of virtues on the wall will not sort that out for them.
The mismatch becomes easier to picture when an English or Filipino teacher is assigned Chemistry, Physics, or Math. She will review, watch tutorials, ask the Science teacher next door, and probably make it work. Teachers are resourceful that way. But there is a difference between learning enough tonight for tomorrow’s lesson and having years of preparation behind what you teach. Explaining Newton’s laws or spotting exactly where a trigonometric solution went wrong asks for something deeper. The students may never know how many extra hours went into that lesson. The teacher does.
There is evidence that this matters for students too. PIDS found a moderate positive relationship between specialization alignment and examination scores, with students taught by specialists generally doing better. That does not mean a teacher with the “right” degree is automatically good, nor does it mean someone teaching outside the field cannot be excellent. We all know examples on both sides. Teaching is much too human to fit neatly into that equation. Still, specialization cannot simply be dismissed as a detail for Human Resources to check on a résumé.
I also understand the school head caught in the middle of all this. A principal in a small town cannot order a Biology teacher the way the office orders bond paper. Plantilla positions are limited. Enrollment changes. Teachers retire, transfer, or leave for better opportunities. Some specializations are simply difficult to fill. But Monday comes anyway. The students are sitting there, the bell rings, and somebody has to enter the room. Sometimes assigning a teacher outside the field is not bad management. Sometimes it is simply the least bad choice available.
The trouble begins when a stopgap becomes standard practice. PIDS points to recruitment, workforce planning, training, and better coordination. Colleges of education belong in that conversation too. The teachers they prepare should better reflect the specializations schools actually need, especially in fields where shortages persist. That takes better coordination with DepEd, CHED, and the schools themselves. None of this can be solved by asking teachers to keep adjusting. We already know Filipino teachers can adjust. They have been proving that for years. Perhaps the more useful question is why we keep requiring so many of them to.
And I keep coming back to Values Education. Schools talk a great deal about character formation. We paint core values on walls, put them in handbooks, repeat them during orientations, and carefully write them into our vision and mission statements. Yet only 6 percent of ESP/Values Education teachers in the data were matched to the field. Physical Sciences was even lower at 2 percent. Biological Sciences stood at 20 percent, while Agriculture and Fisheries and MAPEH were at 30 percent each. That is not an indictment of the teachers. Quite the opposite. It tells us how much extra weight we have quietly asked them to carry.
Tomorrow, that Filipino major will probably walk into her Values Education class anyway. Maybe she stayed up late reading. Maybe she messaged a colleague, changed her activity twice, then changed it back. By the time she faces her students, she may be prepared enough that nobody thinks twice about what her diploma actually says.
And yes, kaya ng teacher. Teachers have been showing us that for years.
Maybe the problem is that we have heard those words so often, we no longer ask why they always have to.
***
Doc H fondly describes himself as a “student of and for life” who, like many others, aspires to a life-giving and why-driven world grounded in social justice and the pursuit of happiness. His views do not necessarily reflect those of the institutions he is employed or connected with.
Comments (0)
LEAVE A REPLY
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!
Related Articles

The takeover
Iloilo City loves to pat itself on the back for the river. We built a beautiful Esplanade and won global awards for clearing out the debris. The water reflects the sunset perfectly. But look under the surface. The narrative falls apart. The Iloilo River is suffocating. A recent UPV College of Fisheries and Ocean Sciences

The untenable status quo
Filipinos living in the Land Down Under see the health services delivered by the state and ask why this cannot be done back home. The sad reality is that our public health system offers very little relief for the people. I recall the story of a 45-year-old construction worker from

The rise of the Gen Z cinephile
By Noel Galon de Leon I recently came across a feature published by The New York Times about the growing number of teenagers and young adults returning to movie theaters in the United States. Interestingly, Gen Z audiences are not just watching blockbuster films. They are also seeking out independent productions, classic films, and other
